Sovrun Cattle - The Sagebrush Saga of Cliven Bundy
Moderators: Prof, Judge Roy Bean
-
- A Balthazar of Quatloosian Truth
- Posts: 13806
- Joined: Mon Jul 04, 2005 7:17 pm
Re: Sovrun Cattle - The Sagebrush Saga of Cliven Bundy
Speaking of someone who is several short a Happy Meal. He really is dumbern' a rock.
The fact that you sincerely and wholeheartedly believe that the “Law of Gravity” is unconstitutional and a violation of your sovereign rights, does not absolve you of adherence to it.
-
- Knight Templar of the Sacred Tax
- Posts: 7668
- Joined: Sat May 19, 2007 12:59 pm
- Location: Texas
Re: Sovrun Cattle - The Sagebrush Saga of Cliven Bundy
The Federal criminal charges against Cliven Bundy are found in a 32 page criminal complaint, and include one count of conspiracy to commit an offense against the United States, one count of assault on a Federal officer by use of a deadly weapon and aiding and abetting, two counts of use and carrying of a firearm in relation to a crime of violence and aiding and abetting, one count of interfering with commerce by extortion and aiding and abetting, and one count of obstruction of the administration of justice and aiding and abetting.
See United States v. Bundy, Complaint, Feb. 11, 2016, case no. 2:16-mj-00127-PAL, U.S. District Court for the District of Nevada (Las Vegas Div.).
See United States v. Bundy, Complaint, Feb. 11, 2016, case no. 2:16-mj-00127-PAL, U.S. District Court for the District of Nevada (Las Vegas Div.).
"My greatest fear is that the audience will beat me to the punch line." -- David Mamet
-
- Slavering Minister of Auto-erotic Insinuation
- Posts: 3759
- Joined: Thu Sep 30, 2010 9:35 am
- Location: Quatloos Immigration Control
Re: Sovrun Cattle - The Sagebrush Saga of Cliven Bundy
For anyone not following this live/on the Fogbow, the last guy has given himself up. It's all over.
"There is something about true madness that goes beyond mere eccentricity." Will Self
-
- Slavering Minister of Auto-erotic Insinuation
- Posts: 3759
- Joined: Thu Sep 30, 2010 9:35 am
- Location: Quatloos Immigration Control
Re: Sovrun Cattle - The Sagebrush Saga of Cliven Bundy
It's being said that the above is good for up to 42 years inside.Famspear wrote:The Federal criminal charges against Cliven Bundy are found in a 32 page criminal complaint, and include one count of conspiracy to commit an offense against the United States, one count of assault on a Federal officer by use of a deadly weapon and aiding and abetting, two counts of use and carrying of a firearm in relation to a crime of violence and aiding and abetting, one count of interfering with commerce by extortion and aiding and abetting, and one count of obstruction of the administration of justice and aiding and abetting.
See United States v. Bundy, Complaint, Feb. 11, 2016, case no. 2:16-mj-00127-PAL, U.S. District Court for the District of Nevada (Las Vegas Div.).
"There is something about true madness that goes beyond mere eccentricity." Will Self
-
- Gunners Mate
- Posts: 46
- Joined: Mon Apr 06, 2015 4:20 pm
- Location: Puget Sound, WA
Re: Sovrun Cattle - The Sagebrush Saga of Cliven Bundy
Assuming Cliven lawyers up, and actually takes his lawyers advice, plays nice etc. What kind of a sentence is he likely looking at? Will all those unpaid grazing fees figure in it? Father and son(s) share a prison cell?Re: Sovrun Cattle - The Sagebrush Saga of Cliven Bundy
Post by Famspear » Thu Feb 11, 2016 8:53 pm
The Federal criminal charges against Cliven Bundy are found in a 32 page criminal complaint, and include one count of conspiracy to commit an offense against the United States, one count of assault on a Federal officer by use of a deadly weapon and aiding and abetting, two counts of use and carrying of a firearm in relation to a crime of violence and aiding and abetting, one count of interfering with commerce by extortion and aiding and abetting, and one count of obstruction of the administration of justice and aiding and abetting.
See United States v. Bundy, Complaint, Feb. 11, 2016, case no. 2:16-mj-00127-PAL, U.S. District Court for the District of Nevada (Las Vegas Div.).
-
- Grand Master Consul of Quatloosia
- Posts: 830
- Joined: Tue Jul 01, 2003 3:19 am
- Location: Seattle
Re: Sovrun Cattle - The Sagebrush Saga of Cliven Bundy
Cliven Bundy Criminal Complaint (filed 2/11/2016):
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF NEVADA
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
Plaintiff,
v.
CLIVEN D. BUNDY,
Defendant.
)
)
) CRIMINAL COMPLAINT
)
) Case No.: 2:16-mj-00127-PAL
) VIOLATIONS:
)
) 18 U.S.C. § 371 - Conspiracy to Commit
) An Offense Against the United States;
)
) 18 U.S.C. § lll(b) -Assault on a Federal
) Law Enforcement Officer;
)
) 18 U.S.C. § 924(c) - Use and Carry of a
) Firearm In Relation to a Crime of
) Violence;
)
) 18 U.S.C. § 1503 - Obstruction of the
) Administration of Justice;
)
) 18 U.S.C. § 1951 - Interference with
) Commerce by Extortion;
)
) 18 U.S.C. § 2 -Aiding and Abetting
BEFORE the United States Magistrate Judge, Las Vegas, Nevada, Joel P.
Willis, Special Agent, Federal Bureau of Investigation, Complainant herein, bein
first duly sworn deposes and states as follows:
COUNT ONE
Conspiracy to Commit an Offense Against the United States
(Title 18, United States Code, Section 371)
Beginning in at least March 2014 and continuing to on or about the date o
this Complaint, in the State and Federal District of Nevada and elsewhere,
CLIVEN D. BUNDY,
defendant herein, did conspire, confederate, and agree with others to commit a
offense against the United States, to wit:
a. Assault on a Federal Officer, in violation of Title 18, United
States Code, Sections lll(a)(l) and (b);
b. Use and Carry a Firearm During and In Relation to a Crime of
Violence, in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Section 924(c);
c. Interference with Commerce by Extortion, in violation of Title
18, United States Code; Section 1951; and
d. Obstruction of the Administration of Justice, in violation of Title
18, United States Code, Section 1503.
In furtherance of the conspiracy, defendant BUNDY and other members o
the conspiracy committed, attempted to commit, and caused to be committed, the overt acts described herein and all of those comprising the offenses charged i
Counts Two through Six.
All in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Section 371.
BEFORE the United States Magistrate Judge, Las Vegas, Nevada, Joel P.
Willis, Special Agent, Federal Bureau of Investigation, Complainant herein, bein
first duly sworn deposes and states as follows:
COUNT ONE
Conspiracy to Commit an Offense Against the United States
(Title 18, United States Code, Section 371)
Beginning in at least March 2014 and continuing to on or about the date o
this Complaint, in the State and Federal District of Nevada and elsewhere,
CLIVEN D. BUNDY,
defendant herein, did conspire, confederate, and agree with others to commit a
offense against the United States, to wit:
a. Assault on a Federal Officer, in violation of Title 18, United
States Code, Sections lll(a)(l) and (b);
b. Use and Carry a Firearm During and In Relation to a Crime of
Violence, in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Section 924(c);
c. Interference with Commerce by Extortion, in violation of Title
18, United States Code; Section 1951; and
d. Obstruction of the Administration of Justice, in violation of Title
18, United States Code, Section 1503.
In furtherance of the conspiracy, defendant BUNDY and other members o
the conspiracy committed, attempted to commit, and caused to be committed, the overt acts described herein and all of those comprising the offenses charged i
Counts Two through Six.
All in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Section 371.
COUNT TWO
Assault On a Federal Officer By Use of Deadly And Dangerous Weapon
(Title 18, United States Code, Sections lll(a)(l), (b) and 2)
On or about April 12, 2014, in the State and Federal District of Nevada, an
elsewhere,
CLIVEN D. BUNDY,
defendant herein, aided and abetted by others, did use a dangerous and deadl
weapon to forcibly assault, resist, oppose, impede, intimidate, and interfere wit
federal law enforcement officers while they were engaged in, and on the account of, the performance of their official duties, to wit: guarding and protecting government personnel and equipment located at the Impoundment Site at or near Bunkerville, Nevada, while executing federal court orders to remove cattle from the federal public lands, as described herein.
All in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Sections lll(a)(l) and (b),
1114, and 2.
COUNT THREE
Use and Carry of a Firearm in Relation to a Crime of Violence
(Title 18, United States Code, Sections 924(c) and 2)
On or about April 12, 2014, in the State and Federal District of Nevada, an
elsewhere,
CLIVEN D. BUNDY,
defendant herein, aided and abetted by others, did knowingly use and carry
firearms, which were brandished, during and in relation to a crime of violence for
which he may be prosecuted in a court of the United States, that is, assault on a federal law enforcement officer, in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Section 111(b), as charged in Count Two of this Complaint.
All in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Sections 924(c)(l)(A)(ii) and 2.
COUNT FOUR
Interference with Commerce by Extortion
(Title 18, United States Code, Sections 1951 and 2)
On or about April 12, 2014, in the State and Federal District of Nevada, and
elsewhere,
CLIVEN D. BUNDY,
defendant herein, did obstruct, delay and affect commerce, and attempt to obstruct, delay and affect commerce, and the movement of articles and commodities in such commerce, by extortion, as those terms are defined in Title 18, United States Code, Section 1951, in that defendant BUNDY attempted to obtain approximately 400 head of impounded cattle at or near Bunkerville, Nevada, from the care, custody, and possession of the Special Agent in Charge of impoundment operations of federal public lands at or near Bunkerville, Nevada, their consent having been induced by the wrongful use of force, fear, and violence as described herein.
All in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Sections 195l(a) and 2.
COUNT FIVE
Use and Carry of a Firearm in Relation to a Crime of Violence
(Title 18, United States Code, Sections 924(c) and 2)
On or about April 12, 2014, in the State and Federal District of Nevada and
elsewhere,
CLIVEN D. BUNDY,
defendant herein, aided and abetted by others, did knowingly use and carry
firearms, which were brandished, during and in relation to a crime of violence for
which he may be prosecuted in a court of the United States, that is, extortion by
force, fear and violence, in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Section 1951, as charged in Count Four of this Complaint.
All in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Sections 924(c)(l)(A)(ii) and 2.
COUNT SIX
Obstruction of the Administration of Justice
(Title 18, United States Code, Sections 1503 and 2)
On or about April 12, 2014, in the State and Federal District of Nevada;
CLIVEN D. BUNDY,
defendant herein, aided and abetted by others, did corruptly, and by threats an
force, and by threatening communications, influence, obstruct and impede, an
attempt to influence, obstruct and impede, the due administration of justice, in that the defendant threatened force and violence and used force and violence to impede, obstruct, and thwart the execution of federal court Orders by assaulting and extorting federal officers at the lmpoundment Site near Bunkerville, Nevada as described herein.
All in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Sections 1503 and 2.
In support of probable cause of the aforementioned charges, I state as follows.
1. I have been a Special Agent with the Federal Bureau of Investigation ("FBI") for over 12 years and, since November 2009, I have been assigned to the Las Vegas Field Office. My training in law enforcement includes agency specific training in all aspects of conducting federal criminal investigations, including the planning, preparation, and execution of search warrants and criminal complaints. I am an "investigative or law enforcement officer of the United States" within the meaning of Title 18, United States Code, Section 2510(7), authorized to make arrests and conduct investigations in connection with alleged violations of federal law. Over the course of my career, I have led or participated in numerous federal investigations to include the drafting and execution of search warrants and criminal complaints.
2. I am currently assigned to conduct an investigation into events that occurred in and near Bunkerville, Nevada, during April 2014 in connection with a cattle impoundment operation conducted by federal law enforcement officers. I submit that the evidence adduced during the investigation to date establishes probable cause to believe that, at all times relevant to the Complaint:
SUMMARY
3. Defendant Cliven D. BUNDY ("BUNDY'') was a resident of Bunkerville, Nevada, and the operator of a ranch referred to as "Bundy Ranch." His ranching operations included grazing cattle unlawfully on federal public land.
4. On April 12, 2014, BUNDY and his co-conspirators organized and led a massive armed assault against federal law enforcement officers in and around Bunkerville, Nevada, in order to extort the officers into abandoning approximately 400 head of cattle that were in their lawful care and custody. In addition to conspiring among themselves to plan and execute these crimes, BUNDY and his confederates recruited, organized, and led hundreds of others in using armed force against law enforcement officers in order to achieve their criminal objectives.
5. One of the conspiracy's objectives was to thwart the seizure and removal of defendant BUNDY's cattle from federal public lands. BUNDY had trespassed his cattle on federal public lands for over 20 years, refusing to obtain the legally-required permits or pay the required fees to keep and graze his cattle on the land.
6. Since 1998, BUNDY was under federal Court Order to remove his
trespass cattle, an Order BUNDY refused to recognize or follow. In 2013, a federal
court issued two more Orders for removal, each declaring that, in keeping with the law, the United States was authorized to seize and remove the cattle from the Ian in the event BUNDY refused to do so. BUNDY refused.
7. The removal operation began on April 5, 2014. While it was ongoing, BUNDY and his co-conspirators used deceit and deception to recruit others to help them to force BLM to stop operations, flooding the internet with false and deceitful images and statements to the effect that law enforcement officers were abusing BUNDY and stealing his cattle. Deliberately lying, BUNDY and conspirators pleaded for others to travel to Nevada to "stop the abuse" by "making show of force against [the officers]" in order "to get them to back down" and "return the cattle." By the morning of April 12, hundreds of people, many armed with assault rifles and other firearms, had traveled to Bunkerville, becoming BUNDY' "Followers," conspiring with, and aiding and abetting him and his co-conspirators to execute a plan to recover BUNDY's cattle by force.
8. On the morning of April 12, BUNDY organized his Followers and gave them the order to get the cattle, directing a crowd of hundreds to travel more than five miles to the site where the cattle were corralled. One group of Followers kept law enforcement officers occupied at the main entrance of the site by threatening to enter there, while another group - ultimately consisting of more than 200 Followers led by Co-conspirator 2 - assaulted the site from below, converging on its most vulnerable point: a narrow entrance located in a wash that ran under highway bridges. Seeing the assault unfold, the officers responded to the wash to prevent entry.
9. The 200 Followers in the wash included a significant number brandishing or raising their assault rifles in front of the officers. Some of these gunmen took tactically superior positions on high ground, while others moved in and out of the crowd, masking their movements behind other unarmed Followers. The most immediate threat to the officers came from the bridges where gunmen took sniper positions behind concrete barriers, their assault rifles aimed directly at the officers below.
10. Having seized the tactical advantage, Co-conspirator 2 and the 200 Followers pressed forward to and against the wash entrance, demanding that the officers leave and abandon the cattle, threatening to enter by force if the officers did
not do so. Outnumbered by more than 4:1, unwilling to risk harm to children and
other unarmed bystanders who had accompanied the Followers, and wishing to
avoid the firefight that was sure to follow if they engaged the snipers on the bridge who posed such an obvious threat to their lives, the officers had no choice and were forced to leave and abandon the cattle to BUNDY and his co-conspirators, promptly released and returned the cattle to BUNDY.
11. Thereafter, the conspirators organized armed security patrols an checkpoints in and around BUNDY's property to deter and prevent any future law enforcement actions against BUNDY or his co-conspirators and to protect his cattle from future removal actions, cattle he continued to hold, graze and keep on federal public lands unlawfully and continues to do so as of the date of this Complaint.
TERMS AND DEFINITIONS
12. "Federal public land" or "public land" was land owned by the United States and managed through various agencies of the United States, including, among others, the United States Department of Interior, Bureau of Land Management ("BLM") and National Park Service ("NPS").
13. The BLM and NPS employed Rangers, Officers, and Special Agents to
enforce federal laws and regulations on public land under their management.
14. BLM and NPS Rangers, Officers, and Special Agents were "federal law
enforcement officers" under Title 18, United States Code, Section 115(c)(l), that is, they were officers, agents, and employees of the United States authorized by law to engage in or supervise the prevention, detection, investigation, or prosecution of and violation of federal criminal law.
15. The Bunkerville Allotment ("the Allotment") was an area of federal public land near Bunkerville, Nevada, under the management of BLM. The United States has owned the land comprising the Allotment since 1848, when it was acquired from the nation of Mexico under the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, and has never relinquished ownership.
16. The Lake Mead National Recreational Area ("LMNRA") was an area of federal public land located near or adjacent to the Allotment, under the management of the NPS. The United States has owned the land comprising the LMNRA since 1848, when it was acquired from the nation of Mexico under the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, and has never relinquished ownership.
BUNDY TRESPASSED CATTLE ON PUBLIC LAND AND REFUSED
TO COMPLY WITH FOUR COURT ORDERS TO REMOVE THEM
17. Federal law required a rancher to obtain a grazing permit from the BLM and to pay fees to the United States to graze cattle on the Bunkerville Allotment. Grazing cattle without a permit constituted a trespass on public land.
18. From 1993 to the date of this Complaint, BUNDY knowingly refuse to pay fees or obtain permits as he kept and grazed his cattle on the Allotment year round, constituting a continuing trespass on public land.
19. In 1998, and because of BUNDYs continuing trespass, the United States District Court for the District of Nevada (hereinafter "District Court" or "Federal Court") Ordered BUNDY to remove his cattle permanently from the Allotment. BUNDY deliberately ignored the Order and continued to trespass by keeping and grazing his cattle unlawfully on public land.
20. In 1999, the District Court fined BUNDY for each day he refused to remove his cattle. BUNDY refused to pay the fines and continued to trespass by keeping and grazing his cattle unlawfully on public land.
21. By 2012, BUNDYs herd had multiplied substantially and spread into the LMNRA where BUNDY kept and grazed them year-round, refusing to pay fees or obtain permits, constituting a continuing trespass on public land.
22. In 2013, the District Court issued two Orders. One ordered BUNDY to remove his trespass cattle permanently from the LMNRA and the other re-affirmed the 1998 and 1999 Orders that required him to remove his cattle permanently from the Allotment. Both Orders declared that, in keeping with the law, the United States was authorized to seize and remove BUNDYs trespass cattle if he did not comply with the Court's Orders. One of the Orders expressly stated that BUNDY was "not to interfere" with any removal.
23. BUNDY ignored the Orders and continued to keep and graze his
trespass cattle unlawfully on public land.
THE BLM PLANNED TO SEIZE AND REMOVE THE CATTLE
FROM THE PUBLIC LANDS PURSUANT TO COURT ORDERS
24. In keeping with the law and the 2013 federal court Orders, the BLM planned to seize and remove BUNDY's trespass cattle, following well-established rules and regulations governing this procedure, referred to hereinafter collectively as "impound" or "impoundment."
25. A preliminary survey revealed that the BLM would have to impound almost 1,000 head of trespass cattle scattered over hundreds of thousands of acre of arid and difficult terrain. Given these circumstances, BLM estimated that it would take a month or more to complete the impoundment.
26. It was part of the plan that BLM would establish a base of operation (hereinafter referred to as "the Impoundment Site") located on the public lands near Bunkerville, about 7 miles away from Bundy Ranch in an area commonly referred to as the Toquop wash.
27. It was part of the plan that on February 17, 2014, the BLM entered into a contract with a civilian contractor in Utah to round-up and gather the trespass cattle. The contract required the contractor to bring people and equipment to Nevada to conduct impoundment operations.
28. It was part of the plan that the civilian contractor and crew would gather and move the trespass cattle from public land into corrals at the Impoundment Site where they would be held until such time as they could be further transported.
29. It was part of the plan that on March 20, 2014, BLM entered into a contract for the services of an auctioneer in Utah. The contract required the trespass cattle to be trucked from the Impoundment Site in Nevada to the contract auctioneer in Utah, who would then sell them at public sale.
30. It was part of the plan that BLM would use BLM and NPS Rangers, Off'icers, and Special Agents to provide security for impoundment operations, including securing the cattle at the Impoundment Site and protecting the civilian contractors and government employees engaged in impoundment operations.
31. It was part of the plan that BLM designated the Special Agent-in-Charge of BLM's Nevada and Utah region (hereinafter the "SAC") to lead impoundment operations.
BUNDY THREATENED TO "DO WHATEVER IT TAKES"
TO PREVENT THE IMPOUNDMENT OF HIS CATTLE
32. On October 23, 2012, and in connection with legal proceeding culminating in the 2013 Court Orders, BUNDY threatened to interfere with an impoundment by stating that he "would do whatever it takes" to stop the impoundment. When asked whether that included soliciting support from others to help him, BUNDY responded: "Yes."
33. On March 14, 2014, the BLM formally notified BUNDY that impoundment operations would take place.
34. On March 15, 2014, BUNDY threatened to interfere by stating publically that he "[was] ready to do battle" with the BLM and he would "do whatever it takes" to protect "his property."
35. On March 17, 2014, a BLM Special Agent notified one of BUNDY' adult sons that the Special Agent was available to answer any questions about the impoundment operation. BUNDY's son became angry and threatened to interfere, stating that he and his family would "do whatever it takes" and he would "have several hundred" with him to prevent the BLM from removing the trespass cattle. When asked whether his use of "whatever it takes" included physical force or violence, BUNDY's son replied: "I will do whatever it takes; you interpret that the way you want."
36. On March 24, 2014, BUNDY threatened to interfere, stating publically that he intended to "organize lots of groups" to "come from hundreds of miles away' and he was in a "range war" with BLM that could "last a long time."
37. On March 25, 2014, BUNDY threatened to interfere, stating publically that: "BUNDY's ready ... whenever [the federal government's] got the guts to try it tell them to come ... I'll do whatever it takes."
38. On March 28, 2014, BUNDY threatened to interfere, stating publically that "all of those cowboys are going to be thieves who steal my cattle ... [i]t's like
they're staging for a war ... I told them I'd do whatever it takes ... I'll stick with
that."
BUNDY CARRIED OUT HIS THREATS
BYCONSPIRING TO LIE, THREATEN FORCE
AND VIOLENCE AND USE FORCE AND VIOLENCE
A. Object and Nature of the Conspiracy.
39. The scope, nature, and objects of the conspiratorial agreement were to use threats of force and violence and actual force and violence to: (1) impede, obstruct and interfere with BLM's impoundment operation; (2) obtain BUNDY'
impounded cattle from federal law enforcement officers; (3) threaten, intimidate and prevent by force federal law enforcement officers from taking action against the conspirators; and (4) threaten, intimidate and prevent by force federal law enforcement officers from taking law enforcement actions against BUNDY and his co-conspirators and prevent by force BLM from exercising regulatory and law
enforcement authority over the public lands.
40. In order to achieve the objects of the conspiracy, BUNDY conspired, confederated, and agreed to commit numerous federal offenses, as charged herein.
B. Manner and Means of the Conspiracy.
41. To achieve his objectives, BUNDY and his co-conspirators recruited, organized, and led a force of hundreds of people to threaten and use force and
violence to prevent the law enforcement officers from discharging their duties and to coerce their consent to abandon the cattle that were, pursuant to court order, lawfully in their care and custody and which they were duty bound to protect.
42. As a part of the manner and means of the conspiracy, BUNDY and his
co-conspirators, among other things:
a. Used deceit and deception to knowingly recruit Followers, that is, to encourage, counsel, and incite others to travel to Bundy Ranch for the unlawful purposes of interfering with impoundment operations, obstructing execution of federal court orders, and using force and violence against federal law enforcement officers while they were performing their duties.
b. Used the internet and other facilities in interstate commerce to knowingly broadcast false, deceitful, and deceptive images and messages for the purpose of recruiting Followers.
c. Used the internet and other facilities in interstate commerce to encourage, counsel, and incite Followers to bring guns to Bundy Ranch for the unlawful purposes of interfering with impoundment operations, obstructing the execution of federal court orders, and using force and violence against federal law enforcement officers to prevent them from discharging their duties.
d. Traveled in interstate commerce and used other facilities in interstate commerce to threaten force, violence, and economic harm to contractors providing services to the BLM during impoundment operations.
e. Threatened and used force and violence against BLM civilian employees engaged in impoundment operations for the purpose of obstructing the execution of federal court orders and interfering with impoundment operations.
f. Counseled, incited, and led Followers to use, carry, brandish, and aim firearms, including assault rifles, for the purpose of assaulting federal law enforcement officers.
g. Counseled, incited, and led Followers to use, carry, brandish, and aim firearms, including assault rifles, for the purpose of extorting federal law enforcement officers.
h. Organized Followers into body guards, armed patrols, and security checkpoints for the purpose of using threats, force, violence, and intimidation to protect the conspirators, prevent law enforcement actions against the conspirators, prevent the execution of federal court orders, and prevent law enforcement officers from discharging their duties.
c. Roles of the Conspirators.
43. BUNDY was the leader, orgamzer, and chief beneficiary of the conspiracy, possessing ultimate authority over the scope, manner, and means of conspiratorial operations and receiving the economic benefits of the extortion.
44. BUNDY and Co-Conspirators 1, 2, 3, and 4 were leaders organizers of the conspiracy who, among other things: recruited Followers; interfered with impoundment operations through threats and use of force and violence; interfered with impoundment operations by attempting to extort BLM contractors; led an armed assault against federal law enforcement officers; delivered extortionate demands to law enforcement officers; and extorted federal law enforcement officers. Co-Conspirators 1, 2, 3, and 4 have been arrested and are detained on federal charges lodged in another district.
D. Overt Acts in Furtherance of the Conspiracy.
49. It was a part of the conspiracy that from March 28 to April 11, 2014, and for the purpose of carrying out the objects of the conspiracy, BUNDY and his co-conspirators performed, or caused to be performed, the following overt acts, among many others.
1. March 28 to April 11: The Conspirators Interfered with
Impoundment Operations and Used Deceit and Deception to
Recruit Followers.
50. On or about March 28, 2014, BUNDY and others working with him, blocked a convoy of vehicles carrying horses and equipment intended for use in impoundment operations, confronting and threatening civilian contractors, endangering the safety of the personnel m the convoy, and interfering with impoundment operations.
51. Shortly thereafter, and in an effort to recruit Followers, BUNDY caused the broadcast of a video of the confrontation with the contractors entitled "Range War," depicting images captured during the confrontation, combining the with false, deceitful and deceptive statements to the effect that the BLM was stealing BUNDYs cattle.
52. On or about April 2, 2014, Co-conspirator 1 traveled from Nevada to Utah to threaten force, violence, and economic harm to the contract auctioneer providing services to the BLM, by, among other things, entering upon the contractor's property for the purpose of interfering with business operations, threatening and intimidating customers and employees, interfering with business operations, and threatening to shut down the business if the contractor fulfilled his contractual obligations with BLM.
53. On or about April 5, 2014, BUNDY threatened force and violence against federal law enforcement officers by publically stating, among other things: "I've done quite a bit so far to keep my cattle, but I guess it's not been enough ... they took 75 of my cattle today ... I have said I'd do what it takes to keep my cattle
so I guess it is going to have to be more physical."
54. On or about April 6, 2014, co-conspirator 1 and another conspirator interfered with impoundment operations by positioning themselves to block a BLM convoy and refusing to leave the area when asked to do so. Failing to leave after repeated requests, a co-conspirator was arrested by law enforcement officers.
55. Shortly thereafter, BUNDY caused images of the arrest to be broadcasted over the internet, combining them with false, deceitful and deceptive statements to the effect that the BLM supposedly: employed snipers against Bundy family members; used excessive force during the arrest; and arrested a conspirator for exercising his First Amendment rights.
56. On or about April 7, 2014, Co-conspirator 2 traveled from Arizona to the Bundy Ranch in Nevada.
57. On or about April 7, 2014, Co-conspirator 3 in Montana, contacted BUNDY in Nevada, by telephone.
58. On or about April 7, 2014, Co-conspirator 3, who referred to himself a leader of a network he referred to as Operation Mutual Aid ("OMA"), used the internet and other facilities in interstate commerce to recruit others whom Co-conspirator 3 referred to as "militia" belonging to the OMA network. Attempting to incite the so-called OMA "militia" members to travel to Bundy Ranch for unlawful purposes, Co-conspirator 3 falsely, deceptively, and deceitfully stated, among other things, that the ranch was surrounded by BLM snipers, the Bundy family was isolated, and BLM wanted BUNDY dead.
59. On or about April 7, 2014, BUNDY and others working with him established a site only minutes travel distance from the Bundy Ranch along Nevada State Route 170, a state road that also served as the main route between the Impoundment Site and the public land where impoundment operations were taking place. Strategically located between the Impoundment Site and various ingress and egress points to public land, the location of the site served as both a natural vantage point from which to observe impoundment operations and a potential choke-point for disrupting BLM convoys. Conspicuous for, among other things, a stage and two tall flagpoles, one of which flew the Nevada State flag above the flag of the United States, this site (hereinafter referred to as "the Staging Site") served as a base of operations from which the conspirators made speeches, received and organize Followers as they arrived at Bundy Ranch, and gathered and organized Follower before initiating their assaults on federal law enforcement officers.
60. On or about April 8, 2014, Co-conspirator 4 in California, contacted
BUNDY in Nevada, by telephone.
61. On or about April 8, 2014, Co-conspirator 4 and BUNDY broadcasted messages over the internet. Using deceit, deception, and threats to incite others to travel to Bundy Ranch for unlawful purposes, BUNDY told listeners, among other things, that: "they have my house surrounded ... the federal government is stealing my property ... [the BLM] are armed with assault rifles ... they have snipers ... haven't called no militia but, hey, that looks like where we are ... there is a strong army out here ... we are going to have to take our land back ... somebody is going to have to back off ... we the people will put our boots down and walk over these people ... they are up against a man who will do whatever it takes."
62. In that same broadcast, Co-conspirator 4 used threats to incite listeners to travel to Bundy Ranch for unlawful purposes, telling listeners, among other things, that: "if this is not the issue right now where we stand and fight to the absolute death there is no other option; the federal government must get out of the State of Nevada ... if they don't want it to be peaceful it is by their choice ... I'm calling on all Americans anywhere in the vicinity of Clark County, Nevada ... if you're in Nevada and can legally carry, get weapons out there, o.k .... we are going to stand and fight in Clark County, Nevada ... they will leave or else."
63. On or about April 8, 2014, Co-conspirator 3 sent a message from Montana to Pennsylvania to another person who referred to himself as one of the leaders in OMA, stating, among other things, that it was "time to invite everyone to the first annual Patriots (sic) Picnic at the Bundy Ranch" and telling the 0MA leader that the Bundys "still want help."
64. On or about April 8, 2014, and for the purpose of recruiting Followers, Co-Conspirator 3 sent a message over the internet, stating that Co-Conspirator 3 had spoken with BUNDY and that "he knows we're coming and has opened his Iand up to everyone willing ... OMA is moving ... not going public with this until more
are enroute."
65. On or about April 8, 2014, Co-conspirator 3 caused an email to be sent to OMA members stating: "we have made the decision to mobilize in Nevada, unit are underway as I type this ... the feds arrested some protestors today, and the words 'we need you now' were uttered ... we have approximately 150 responding, but that number is [gr]owing by the hour." The message provided directions an
grid coordinates to Bundy Ranch.
66. On or about and between April 8 and 9, 2014, Co-conspirator 4 traveled from California to Bundy Ranch in Nevada.
67. On or about and between April 8 and 9, 2014, Co-conspirator traveled from Montana to Bundy Ranch in Nevada.
68. On or about April 9, 2014, Co-conspirators 3 and 4 met with BUNDY and other conspirators at Bundy Ranch.
69. On the morning of April 9, 2014, Co-conspirator 4 met with the SAC and stated that he was acting as a liaison between Bundy Followers and the BLM. Threatening the SAC, Co-conspirator 4 stated: "What are you guys going to do if 10,000 people show up? ... Are you prepared for this? ... I don't believe in firing single bullet unless in absolute defense and it's legal and constitutional."
70. On or about April 9, 2014, and for the purpose of inciting others to travel to Bundy Ranch for an unlawful purpose, the conspirators caused a message to be broadcasted over the internet, stating: "The Bundy family has requested help from militia groups including Operation Mutual Aid, 3 Percenters club, freedom fighters, and other operations to come and stand with us and regain our rights and freedom."
71. On April 9, 2014, and for the purpose of inciting others to travel to Bundy Ranch for an unlawful purpose, Co-conspirator 4 broadcasted a message over the internet, stating, among other things: "the BLM knows if they are outnumbered and outgunned ... they will stand down ... we want BLM to get out of the state of
Nevada ... I fully expect the standoff will occur when thousands go to repossess the rightfully owned property of the Bundys ... we need strength in numbers."
72. On or about April 9, 2014, Co-conspirator 1, and others working with him, traveled for a second time from Nevada to Utah to threaten force, violence, and
economic loss to the contract auctioneer providing services to the BLM by, among
other things: intimidating customers; interfering with business operations; and instilling fear and apprehension in customers and employees.
73. On or about April 9, 2014, and for the purpose of inciting others to travel to Bundy Ranch for an unlawful purpose, Co-conspirator 4 broadcasted message over the internet, stating, among other things: "now is the time to show up for something like this ... we need ten thousand people to come here ... I only have
one fear is that people that don't respond to this call ... it's time to make a stand
against tyranny ... we need to let everyone know that BLM has zero authority."
74. On April 9, 2014, Co-conspirators 2 and 4 assaulted federal officers by, among other things: intercepting and blocking a convoy of BLM vehicles engaged in
impoundment operations; colliding an ATV into a truck in the convoy in order t
stall the truck and gain entry by force; attempting to forcibly gain entrance to the
stalled truck; attempting to throw a rock at law enforcement officers while the
officers were protecting the truck and the civilian passengers inside; threatening physical harm to law enforcement officers while they were protecting the truck and the civilian passengers inside; and causing physical contact with an officer while the officer was engaged in protecting the truck and the civilian passengers inside.
75. On or about April 9, 2014, and for the purpose of inciting others to travel to Bundy Ranch for an unlawful purpose, Co-Conspirator 4 broadcasted message over the internet, stating, among other things: "we were serious about stopping the convoy ... [the BLM] were caught off guard and tried to push past us ... they couldn't do it ... we outnumbered them and they retreated ... we know how they will come back after they retreat ... my biggest fear is if we don't respond ... they retreated and will come back with a bigger force ... we need to disperse them with tens of thousands ... we want BLM to always retreat because we will always outnumber them ... we have all been waiting for that ultimate moment ... there is so much at stake ... we can win with numbers ... I've got people coming from Michigan ... militia members who are fully armed are here ... it's good to watch the BLM with its tail between its legs . . . get out here . . . this is going to get exciting ... ultimately get the feds to leave."
76. On April 10, 2014, and for the purpose of inciting others to travel to Bundy Ranch for an unlawful purpose, Co-conspirator 3 caused an email to be sent to self-described "militia" members of OMA under the subject line "Bundy Objectives," as follows:
Nevada Alert! We are requesting help to distribute the following to
any and all media, blog, patriot groups etc.
1. Secure the Bundy family from government incursion which includes protection of all personnel responding in support of the Bundys i.e. Protestors, extended family, and friends.
2. To return the confiscated Clark County Nevada property currently blocke4 by federal personnel to it's (sic) rightful stewards, the people of Clark County, Nevada.
3. To secure and return to Mr. Bundys (sic) ranch the mounting number of cattle which have been confiscated by BLM agents and private contractors.
These objectives are in cohesion with Cliven Bundy and the Bundy
ranch ....
77. On or about April 10, 2014, and for the purpose of inciting others to travel to Bundy Ranch for an unlawful purpose, Co-conspirator 4 broadcasted message over the internet, stating, among other things: "there is not enough militia here ... we have 1OOO's of very organized constitutional militia ... they are trickling in ... where we will fail is for us not to at least match the overwhelming
force . . . we have about 50 members here now ... where we will fail is for us not to not match the BLM force ... we need a show of force ... we did a recon and found that BLM have hundreds of vehicles . . BLM needs to vacate immediately ... we need the numbers for the feds to leave . . they will come back with a bigger force ... we need tens of thousands of people so they retreat ... come out here ... we've a been waiting for the ultimate moment ... we can win with numbers ... get out here no matter where you are ... militia members here are fully armed."
78. On or about April 10, 2014, and for the purpose of inciting other to travel to Bundy Ranch for an unlawful purpose, Co-conspirator 4 broadcasted message over the internet, stating, among other things: "there is a court order, but the court is corrupt . . . BLM believes they are acting constitutionally . . . BLM is in violation of every God-given right of every human being ... [BLM's] closure order are 'shelter in place' ... [BLM] aimed AR-15's at me [during confrontation on April
9] . . . Waco and Ruby Ridge was a show of force by government and violate sovereign rights ... if we have 10,000 people, [the BLM] will have to get past us."
79. On the morning of April 11, 2014, Co-Conspirator 4 met with the SAC and stated, among other things: "we are going to have a face-to-face confrontation ... we have thousands of people . . . we are going to come here and it is non negotiable ... if that comes about, we want to make sure that any [BLM officer]
who wants to stand down will not be retaliated against . . . this is non negotiable ... if you make the decision to go face-to-face and someone gets hurt we are going to hold you responsible . . . tell D.C. that the justification for this is from a corrupt court . . . I'm relaying a message ... if anyone is acting unconstitutionally they will be arrested ... I came here to allow you to prevent a scenario where someone get hurt."
80. By on or about April 11, 2014, hundreds of Followers traveled to Nevada, many armed with assault rifles and other firearms and many of who identified themselves as "militia" and wore military style clothing and equipment.
81. By on or about April 11, 2014, Co-conspirator 3 and others working
with him, received the armed Followers, including those who identified themselves as "militia." The leaders of the conspiracy placed them into camps, which the leaders described as "militia camps," from which camps the conspirators would organize and deploy the militia and other armed Followers.
82. By on or about April 11, 2014, Co-conspirator 3, and others working with him, organized armed Followers and militia into patrols and armed checkpoints to provide security to the conspirators and their criminal enterprise.
2. April 12: The Conspirators Assaulted and Extorted Law Enforcement Officers.
83. It was further a part of the conspiracy that on April 12, 2014, BUNDY and his co-conspirators, organized, led and executed a mass assault on federal la
enforcement officers in order to obtain the seized cattle, as follows.
84. By the morning of April 12, the BLM had seized approximately 400 head of cattle and had them corralled at the Impoundment Site, awaiting further shipment out of the state of Nevada.
85. On the morning of April 12, BUNDY led a rally of hundreds of his Followers, including militia and other armed Followers, at the Rally Site where he told them that "God [is] going to be with us" and that it was time "to take our land back." He then commanded his Followers to get the cattle.
86. BUNDY directed his Followers that "horse people" (Followers ridinghorses) would leave the Rally Site and travel a dirt road to the Toquop wash, the location of the Impoundment Site, a distance of about 3.5 miles. While that was
happening, so commanded BUNDY, the other Followers, including militia and
other armed Followers, were to travel the highway by vehicle, a distance of about 5 miles, and "shut down the freeway" at the Impoundment Site. The Followers, as directed BUNDY, were then to meet with the "horse people" in the Toquop wash.
87. The Followers did as BUNDY ordered. Armed with their weapons, the Followers hurriedly loaded themselves into cars and trucks and moved en masse to
the Impoundment Site, jamming the roads and slowing traffic on northbound I-15 to a trickle, making it difficult for state and local law enforcement vehicles to respond. When the Followers arrived at the Impoundment Site, they jumped out of their vehicles and many of them moved quickly on foot to a position across from the main entrance.
88. Other Followers took positions on the bridges overlooking the Impoundment Site. The few local law enforcement officers who were able to respond formed a human line in the I-15 median to block the Followers, many of whom carried and brandished assault rifles, from entering at the main entrance to the Impoundment Site.
89. Many Followers then moved a few hundred yards east and below the main entrance and met Co-conspirator 2 in the Toquop wash, gathering about 15
yards opposite from a makeshift metal rail gate that blocked the wash entrance
beneath the southbound bridge of I-15.
90. By 12:00 noon, over 400 of BUNDY's Followers had converged upon the Impoundment Site, many of the Followers were comprised of Bundy's militia openly brandishing assault rifles, others bearing side arms, the combined group grossly outnumbering the officers that protected the site. About 60 yards across
from the metal rail gate at the wash entrance to the site, between the north an
southbound I-15 bridges, a crowd of more than 270 Followers ~ a combination o
militia and non-militia on foot and about 40 men and women on horseback - formed into a line along the bottom of the wash about 60 yards across. This position was guarded by about 50 federal law enforcement officers, positioned beginning about 10 to 20 yards behind the gate.
91. The officers at the gate were dangerously exposed. They were in the open on low ground at the bottom of the wash, below highway bridges that towered more than 40 feet above them and surrounded on the sides by steep embankment of high ground. The terrain acted like a funnel with them at the bottom and no natural cover or concealment to protect them from the gunmen on the high ground, their only protection being their body armor and the vehicles they happened to drive to the gate. At this point approximately 40 Followers were either carrying or brandishing firearms in front of the officers, many of them moving in and out of the line, taking high ground on the sides of the wash. Meanwhile, more than 200 Followers carried or brandished firearms while on the bridges that towered more than 40 feet above the officers, some of them aiming assault rifles at the officers from covered and concealed sniper positions.
92. The officers guarding the gate could readily observe gunmen bobbing up and down from behind the concrete barriers that bordered the northbound I-15 bridge, indicating to the officers that the gunmen were acquiring, and determining
the range to, their officer-targets. The officers could also observe armed gunmen
dressed in military-style tactical gear and wearing body armor, moving in and among the unarmed Followers, using them as human shields to mask their movements while still others took tactically superior positions on the sides of the
wash.
93. The Followers' close proximity to the officers, their array and formation in the wash, their refusal to disperse upon command, their angry taunts, their numbers carrying or brandishing firearms, their movement to the gate while brandishing assault rifles and wearing body armor, and their superior sniper positions on the bridge above, all caused the officers to fear immediate bodily harm or death.
94. Around 12: 15, the Followers in the wash, led by Co-conspirator 2, advanced to the gate. The gunmen moved with him, openly brandishing their rifle and taking over-watch positions on the high ground within full view of the tactically
disadvantaged officers, the snipers in concealed positions on and under the bridge
now aiming their assault rifles at the officers. Seeing the combined force arrayed
against them - an organized crowd of more than 400, more than 60 among the crowd carrying or brandishing rifles or pistols, 40 supporters on horseback, militia snipers concealed on the bridges above them with their rifles zeroed-in on the
officers, militia gunmen intermingled with the crowd using the unarmed people t
shield their movement, militia gunmen in over-watch positions on the high ground
the officers believed they were going to be shot and killed. They were stymied
prevented from shooting the gunmen who posed such an obvious threat to their lives out of concern they would spark a firefight that would kill or injure unarmed
people. Unable to surgically remove the deadly threats before them, outnumbered, outgunned, and located in a dangerously exposed and tactically inferior position, the officers knew they were easy targets. They still held their ground.
95. Upon reaching the gate and backed by his gunmen and snipers, Coconspirator
2 told the SAC that he and the rest of his force would not leave until the BLM left the impoundment site. When asked to move his gun-backed crowd away from the gate so the officers could disengage, Co-conspirator 2 refused and demanded that the officers leave first stating, among other things, ''You need to leave ... that's the terms ... no, you need to leave ... you are on Nevada State property ... the time is now ... no, the time is now."
96. To prevent the disaster that was sure to follow if they remained longer, the SAC was forced to give in to Co-conspirator 2's demands and ordered his officer to leave, abandoning the post, the impoundment site, and the cattle to BUNDY.
97. Having made the decision to meet the conspirators' demands, the SAC met with Co-conspirator 1 near the main entrance to the Impoundment Site to negotiate the departure of the law enforcement officers. While the armed Followers held their position below at the wash entrance, Co-conspirator 1 demanded that the BLM officers pack all of the equipment and leave the Impoundment Site within two hours.
98. The law enforcement officers were forced to abandon the Impoundment Site and the cattle to the conspirators and their Followers, who promptly release and returned them to BUNDY and took down the fences comprising the corrals.
3. Continuing Conspiracy - Post-Assault: The Conspirator Organized Bodyguards, Patrols and Checkpoints to Prevent and Deter Future Law Enforcement Actions.
99. It was further a part of the conspiracy that following the April 1 assault and extortion, BUNDY and the co-conspirators took such other actions a necessary to protect themselves and their ill-gotten gains and to further interfere with and prevent future federal law enforcement actions on the public lands.
100. From April 12 to at least the end of May 2014, the BUDNY and the coconspirators established, organized, and maintained militia camps to provide housing and logistical support to armed gunmen who continued to travel to the
Bundy Ranch.
101. From April 12 to at least the end of May 2014, BUNDY and his co conspirators established armed checkpoints and security patrols to prevent and deter law enforcement actions against the conspirators, including recovering the extorted cattle.
102. From April 12, 2014 through September 2014, Co-Conspirator 4 made statements to the SAC, threatening similar assaultive conduct in the event the
BLM attempted further law enforcement actions.
103. From April 12, 2014 through the date of this Complaint, BUNDY made public statements threatening that he would continue to interfere with federal law enforcement actions against him or the cattle.
104. From April 12, 2014 through the date of this Complaint, BUNDY continued to employ body guards to protect him and other co-conspirators fro
federal law enforcement actions.
105. From April 12, 2014, through the date of this Complaint, the BUNDY and his co-conspirators continue to take such actions as necessary to hold, protect, and prevent the impoundment of the extorted cattle and such other trespass cattle that are subject to the 2013 Court Orders.
s__________
Joel P WIllis
Federal Bureau of Investigation
Subscribed and Sworn to before this 11th day of February, 2016.
s__________
Peggy A. Leen
United States Magistrate Judge
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF NEVADA
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
Plaintiff,
v.
CLIVEN D. BUNDY,
Defendant.
)
)
) CRIMINAL COMPLAINT
)
) Case No.: 2:16-mj-00127-PAL
) VIOLATIONS:
)
) 18 U.S.C. § 371 - Conspiracy to Commit
) An Offense Against the United States;
)
) 18 U.S.C. § lll(b) -Assault on a Federal
) Law Enforcement Officer;
)
) 18 U.S.C. § 924(c) - Use and Carry of a
) Firearm In Relation to a Crime of
) Violence;
)
) 18 U.S.C. § 1503 - Obstruction of the
) Administration of Justice;
)
) 18 U.S.C. § 1951 - Interference with
) Commerce by Extortion;
)
) 18 U.S.C. § 2 -Aiding and Abetting
BEFORE the United States Magistrate Judge, Las Vegas, Nevada, Joel P.
Willis, Special Agent, Federal Bureau of Investigation, Complainant herein, bein
first duly sworn deposes and states as follows:
COUNT ONE
Conspiracy to Commit an Offense Against the United States
(Title 18, United States Code, Section 371)
Beginning in at least March 2014 and continuing to on or about the date o
this Complaint, in the State and Federal District of Nevada and elsewhere,
CLIVEN D. BUNDY,
defendant herein, did conspire, confederate, and agree with others to commit a
offense against the United States, to wit:
a. Assault on a Federal Officer, in violation of Title 18, United
States Code, Sections lll(a)(l) and (b);
b. Use and Carry a Firearm During and In Relation to a Crime of
Violence, in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Section 924(c);
c. Interference with Commerce by Extortion, in violation of Title
18, United States Code; Section 1951; and
d. Obstruction of the Administration of Justice, in violation of Title
18, United States Code, Section 1503.
In furtherance of the conspiracy, defendant BUNDY and other members o
the conspiracy committed, attempted to commit, and caused to be committed, the overt acts described herein and all of those comprising the offenses charged i
Counts Two through Six.
All in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Section 371.
BEFORE the United States Magistrate Judge, Las Vegas, Nevada, Joel P.
Willis, Special Agent, Federal Bureau of Investigation, Complainant herein, bein
first duly sworn deposes and states as follows:
COUNT ONE
Conspiracy to Commit an Offense Against the United States
(Title 18, United States Code, Section 371)
Beginning in at least March 2014 and continuing to on or about the date o
this Complaint, in the State and Federal District of Nevada and elsewhere,
CLIVEN D. BUNDY,
defendant herein, did conspire, confederate, and agree with others to commit a
offense against the United States, to wit:
a. Assault on a Federal Officer, in violation of Title 18, United
States Code, Sections lll(a)(l) and (b);
b. Use and Carry a Firearm During and In Relation to a Crime of
Violence, in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Section 924(c);
c. Interference with Commerce by Extortion, in violation of Title
18, United States Code; Section 1951; and
d. Obstruction of the Administration of Justice, in violation of Title
18, United States Code, Section 1503.
In furtherance of the conspiracy, defendant BUNDY and other members o
the conspiracy committed, attempted to commit, and caused to be committed, the overt acts described herein and all of those comprising the offenses charged i
Counts Two through Six.
All in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Section 371.
COUNT TWO
Assault On a Federal Officer By Use of Deadly And Dangerous Weapon
(Title 18, United States Code, Sections lll(a)(l), (b) and 2)
On or about April 12, 2014, in the State and Federal District of Nevada, an
elsewhere,
CLIVEN D. BUNDY,
defendant herein, aided and abetted by others, did use a dangerous and deadl
weapon to forcibly assault, resist, oppose, impede, intimidate, and interfere wit
federal law enforcement officers while they were engaged in, and on the account of, the performance of their official duties, to wit: guarding and protecting government personnel and equipment located at the Impoundment Site at or near Bunkerville, Nevada, while executing federal court orders to remove cattle from the federal public lands, as described herein.
All in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Sections lll(a)(l) and (b),
1114, and 2.
COUNT THREE
Use and Carry of a Firearm in Relation to a Crime of Violence
(Title 18, United States Code, Sections 924(c) and 2)
On or about April 12, 2014, in the State and Federal District of Nevada, an
elsewhere,
CLIVEN D. BUNDY,
defendant herein, aided and abetted by others, did knowingly use and carry
firearms, which were brandished, during and in relation to a crime of violence for
which he may be prosecuted in a court of the United States, that is, assault on a federal law enforcement officer, in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Section 111(b), as charged in Count Two of this Complaint.
All in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Sections 924(c)(l)(A)(ii) and 2.
COUNT FOUR
Interference with Commerce by Extortion
(Title 18, United States Code, Sections 1951 and 2)
On or about April 12, 2014, in the State and Federal District of Nevada, and
elsewhere,
CLIVEN D. BUNDY,
defendant herein, did obstruct, delay and affect commerce, and attempt to obstruct, delay and affect commerce, and the movement of articles and commodities in such commerce, by extortion, as those terms are defined in Title 18, United States Code, Section 1951, in that defendant BUNDY attempted to obtain approximately 400 head of impounded cattle at or near Bunkerville, Nevada, from the care, custody, and possession of the Special Agent in Charge of impoundment operations of federal public lands at or near Bunkerville, Nevada, their consent having been induced by the wrongful use of force, fear, and violence as described herein.
All in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Sections 195l(a) and 2.
COUNT FIVE
Use and Carry of a Firearm in Relation to a Crime of Violence
(Title 18, United States Code, Sections 924(c) and 2)
On or about April 12, 2014, in the State and Federal District of Nevada and
elsewhere,
CLIVEN D. BUNDY,
defendant herein, aided and abetted by others, did knowingly use and carry
firearms, which were brandished, during and in relation to a crime of violence for
which he may be prosecuted in a court of the United States, that is, extortion by
force, fear and violence, in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Section 1951, as charged in Count Four of this Complaint.
All in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Sections 924(c)(l)(A)(ii) and 2.
COUNT SIX
Obstruction of the Administration of Justice
(Title 18, United States Code, Sections 1503 and 2)
On or about April 12, 2014, in the State and Federal District of Nevada;
CLIVEN D. BUNDY,
defendant herein, aided and abetted by others, did corruptly, and by threats an
force, and by threatening communications, influence, obstruct and impede, an
attempt to influence, obstruct and impede, the due administration of justice, in that the defendant threatened force and violence and used force and violence to impede, obstruct, and thwart the execution of federal court Orders by assaulting and extorting federal officers at the lmpoundment Site near Bunkerville, Nevada as described herein.
All in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Sections 1503 and 2.
In support of probable cause of the aforementioned charges, I state as follows.
1. I have been a Special Agent with the Federal Bureau of Investigation ("FBI") for over 12 years and, since November 2009, I have been assigned to the Las Vegas Field Office. My training in law enforcement includes agency specific training in all aspects of conducting federal criminal investigations, including the planning, preparation, and execution of search warrants and criminal complaints. I am an "investigative or law enforcement officer of the United States" within the meaning of Title 18, United States Code, Section 2510(7), authorized to make arrests and conduct investigations in connection with alleged violations of federal law. Over the course of my career, I have led or participated in numerous federal investigations to include the drafting and execution of search warrants and criminal complaints.
2. I am currently assigned to conduct an investigation into events that occurred in and near Bunkerville, Nevada, during April 2014 in connection with a cattle impoundment operation conducted by federal law enforcement officers. I submit that the evidence adduced during the investigation to date establishes probable cause to believe that, at all times relevant to the Complaint:
SUMMARY
3. Defendant Cliven D. BUNDY ("BUNDY'') was a resident of Bunkerville, Nevada, and the operator of a ranch referred to as "Bundy Ranch." His ranching operations included grazing cattle unlawfully on federal public land.
4. On April 12, 2014, BUNDY and his co-conspirators organized and led a massive armed assault against federal law enforcement officers in and around Bunkerville, Nevada, in order to extort the officers into abandoning approximately 400 head of cattle that were in their lawful care and custody. In addition to conspiring among themselves to plan and execute these crimes, BUNDY and his confederates recruited, organized, and led hundreds of others in using armed force against law enforcement officers in order to achieve their criminal objectives.
5. One of the conspiracy's objectives was to thwart the seizure and removal of defendant BUNDY's cattle from federal public lands. BUNDY had trespassed his cattle on federal public lands for over 20 years, refusing to obtain the legally-required permits or pay the required fees to keep and graze his cattle on the land.
6. Since 1998, BUNDY was under federal Court Order to remove his
trespass cattle, an Order BUNDY refused to recognize or follow. In 2013, a federal
court issued two more Orders for removal, each declaring that, in keeping with the law, the United States was authorized to seize and remove the cattle from the Ian in the event BUNDY refused to do so. BUNDY refused.
7. The removal operation began on April 5, 2014. While it was ongoing, BUNDY and his co-conspirators used deceit and deception to recruit others to help them to force BLM to stop operations, flooding the internet with false and deceitful images and statements to the effect that law enforcement officers were abusing BUNDY and stealing his cattle. Deliberately lying, BUNDY and conspirators pleaded for others to travel to Nevada to "stop the abuse" by "making show of force against [the officers]" in order "to get them to back down" and "return the cattle." By the morning of April 12, hundreds of people, many armed with assault rifles and other firearms, had traveled to Bunkerville, becoming BUNDY' "Followers," conspiring with, and aiding and abetting him and his co-conspirators to execute a plan to recover BUNDY's cattle by force.
8. On the morning of April 12, BUNDY organized his Followers and gave them the order to get the cattle, directing a crowd of hundreds to travel more than five miles to the site where the cattle were corralled. One group of Followers kept law enforcement officers occupied at the main entrance of the site by threatening to enter there, while another group - ultimately consisting of more than 200 Followers led by Co-conspirator 2 - assaulted the site from below, converging on its most vulnerable point: a narrow entrance located in a wash that ran under highway bridges. Seeing the assault unfold, the officers responded to the wash to prevent entry.
9. The 200 Followers in the wash included a significant number brandishing or raising their assault rifles in front of the officers. Some of these gunmen took tactically superior positions on high ground, while others moved in and out of the crowd, masking their movements behind other unarmed Followers. The most immediate threat to the officers came from the bridges where gunmen took sniper positions behind concrete barriers, their assault rifles aimed directly at the officers below.
10. Having seized the tactical advantage, Co-conspirator 2 and the 200 Followers pressed forward to and against the wash entrance, demanding that the officers leave and abandon the cattle, threatening to enter by force if the officers did
not do so. Outnumbered by more than 4:1, unwilling to risk harm to children and
other unarmed bystanders who had accompanied the Followers, and wishing to
avoid the firefight that was sure to follow if they engaged the snipers on the bridge who posed such an obvious threat to their lives, the officers had no choice and were forced to leave and abandon the cattle to BUNDY and his co-conspirators, promptly released and returned the cattle to BUNDY.
11. Thereafter, the conspirators organized armed security patrols an checkpoints in and around BUNDY's property to deter and prevent any future law enforcement actions against BUNDY or his co-conspirators and to protect his cattle from future removal actions, cattle he continued to hold, graze and keep on federal public lands unlawfully and continues to do so as of the date of this Complaint.
TERMS AND DEFINITIONS
12. "Federal public land" or "public land" was land owned by the United States and managed through various agencies of the United States, including, among others, the United States Department of Interior, Bureau of Land Management ("BLM") and National Park Service ("NPS").
13. The BLM and NPS employed Rangers, Officers, and Special Agents to
enforce federal laws and regulations on public land under their management.
14. BLM and NPS Rangers, Officers, and Special Agents were "federal law
enforcement officers" under Title 18, United States Code, Section 115(c)(l), that is, they were officers, agents, and employees of the United States authorized by law to engage in or supervise the prevention, detection, investigation, or prosecution of and violation of federal criminal law.
15. The Bunkerville Allotment ("the Allotment") was an area of federal public land near Bunkerville, Nevada, under the management of BLM. The United States has owned the land comprising the Allotment since 1848, when it was acquired from the nation of Mexico under the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, and has never relinquished ownership.
16. The Lake Mead National Recreational Area ("LMNRA") was an area of federal public land located near or adjacent to the Allotment, under the management of the NPS. The United States has owned the land comprising the LMNRA since 1848, when it was acquired from the nation of Mexico under the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, and has never relinquished ownership.
BUNDY TRESPASSED CATTLE ON PUBLIC LAND AND REFUSED
TO COMPLY WITH FOUR COURT ORDERS TO REMOVE THEM
17. Federal law required a rancher to obtain a grazing permit from the BLM and to pay fees to the United States to graze cattle on the Bunkerville Allotment. Grazing cattle without a permit constituted a trespass on public land.
18. From 1993 to the date of this Complaint, BUNDY knowingly refuse to pay fees or obtain permits as he kept and grazed his cattle on the Allotment year round, constituting a continuing trespass on public land.
19. In 1998, and because of BUNDYs continuing trespass, the United States District Court for the District of Nevada (hereinafter "District Court" or "Federal Court") Ordered BUNDY to remove his cattle permanently from the Allotment. BUNDY deliberately ignored the Order and continued to trespass by keeping and grazing his cattle unlawfully on public land.
20. In 1999, the District Court fined BUNDY for each day he refused to remove his cattle. BUNDY refused to pay the fines and continued to trespass by keeping and grazing his cattle unlawfully on public land.
21. By 2012, BUNDYs herd had multiplied substantially and spread into the LMNRA where BUNDY kept and grazed them year-round, refusing to pay fees or obtain permits, constituting a continuing trespass on public land.
22. In 2013, the District Court issued two Orders. One ordered BUNDY to remove his trespass cattle permanently from the LMNRA and the other re-affirmed the 1998 and 1999 Orders that required him to remove his cattle permanently from the Allotment. Both Orders declared that, in keeping with the law, the United States was authorized to seize and remove BUNDYs trespass cattle if he did not comply with the Court's Orders. One of the Orders expressly stated that BUNDY was "not to interfere" with any removal.
23. BUNDY ignored the Orders and continued to keep and graze his
trespass cattle unlawfully on public land.
THE BLM PLANNED TO SEIZE AND REMOVE THE CATTLE
FROM THE PUBLIC LANDS PURSUANT TO COURT ORDERS
24. In keeping with the law and the 2013 federal court Orders, the BLM planned to seize and remove BUNDY's trespass cattle, following well-established rules and regulations governing this procedure, referred to hereinafter collectively as "impound" or "impoundment."
25. A preliminary survey revealed that the BLM would have to impound almost 1,000 head of trespass cattle scattered over hundreds of thousands of acre of arid and difficult terrain. Given these circumstances, BLM estimated that it would take a month or more to complete the impoundment.
26. It was part of the plan that BLM would establish a base of operation (hereinafter referred to as "the Impoundment Site") located on the public lands near Bunkerville, about 7 miles away from Bundy Ranch in an area commonly referred to as the Toquop wash.
27. It was part of the plan that on February 17, 2014, the BLM entered into a contract with a civilian contractor in Utah to round-up and gather the trespass cattle. The contract required the contractor to bring people and equipment to Nevada to conduct impoundment operations.
28. It was part of the plan that the civilian contractor and crew would gather and move the trespass cattle from public land into corrals at the Impoundment Site where they would be held until such time as they could be further transported.
29. It was part of the plan that on March 20, 2014, BLM entered into a contract for the services of an auctioneer in Utah. The contract required the trespass cattle to be trucked from the Impoundment Site in Nevada to the contract auctioneer in Utah, who would then sell them at public sale.
30. It was part of the plan that BLM would use BLM and NPS Rangers, Off'icers, and Special Agents to provide security for impoundment operations, including securing the cattle at the Impoundment Site and protecting the civilian contractors and government employees engaged in impoundment operations.
31. It was part of the plan that BLM designated the Special Agent-in-Charge of BLM's Nevada and Utah region (hereinafter the "SAC") to lead impoundment operations.
BUNDY THREATENED TO "DO WHATEVER IT TAKES"
TO PREVENT THE IMPOUNDMENT OF HIS CATTLE
32. On October 23, 2012, and in connection with legal proceeding culminating in the 2013 Court Orders, BUNDY threatened to interfere with an impoundment by stating that he "would do whatever it takes" to stop the impoundment. When asked whether that included soliciting support from others to help him, BUNDY responded: "Yes."
33. On March 14, 2014, the BLM formally notified BUNDY that impoundment operations would take place.
34. On March 15, 2014, BUNDY threatened to interfere by stating publically that he "[was] ready to do battle" with the BLM and he would "do whatever it takes" to protect "his property."
35. On March 17, 2014, a BLM Special Agent notified one of BUNDY' adult sons that the Special Agent was available to answer any questions about the impoundment operation. BUNDY's son became angry and threatened to interfere, stating that he and his family would "do whatever it takes" and he would "have several hundred" with him to prevent the BLM from removing the trespass cattle. When asked whether his use of "whatever it takes" included physical force or violence, BUNDY's son replied: "I will do whatever it takes; you interpret that the way you want."
36. On March 24, 2014, BUNDY threatened to interfere, stating publically that he intended to "organize lots of groups" to "come from hundreds of miles away' and he was in a "range war" with BLM that could "last a long time."
37. On March 25, 2014, BUNDY threatened to interfere, stating publically that: "BUNDY's ready ... whenever [the federal government's] got the guts to try it tell them to come ... I'll do whatever it takes."
38. On March 28, 2014, BUNDY threatened to interfere, stating publically that "all of those cowboys are going to be thieves who steal my cattle ... [i]t's like
they're staging for a war ... I told them I'd do whatever it takes ... I'll stick with
that."
BUNDY CARRIED OUT HIS THREATS
BYCONSPIRING TO LIE, THREATEN FORCE
AND VIOLENCE AND USE FORCE AND VIOLENCE
A. Object and Nature of the Conspiracy.
39. The scope, nature, and objects of the conspiratorial agreement were to use threats of force and violence and actual force and violence to: (1) impede, obstruct and interfere with BLM's impoundment operation; (2) obtain BUNDY'
impounded cattle from federal law enforcement officers; (3) threaten, intimidate and prevent by force federal law enforcement officers from taking action against the conspirators; and (4) threaten, intimidate and prevent by force federal law enforcement officers from taking law enforcement actions against BUNDY and his co-conspirators and prevent by force BLM from exercising regulatory and law
enforcement authority over the public lands.
40. In order to achieve the objects of the conspiracy, BUNDY conspired, confederated, and agreed to commit numerous federal offenses, as charged herein.
B. Manner and Means of the Conspiracy.
41. To achieve his objectives, BUNDY and his co-conspirators recruited, organized, and led a force of hundreds of people to threaten and use force and
violence to prevent the law enforcement officers from discharging their duties and to coerce their consent to abandon the cattle that were, pursuant to court order, lawfully in their care and custody and which they were duty bound to protect.
42. As a part of the manner and means of the conspiracy, BUNDY and his
co-conspirators, among other things:
a. Used deceit and deception to knowingly recruit Followers, that is, to encourage, counsel, and incite others to travel to Bundy Ranch for the unlawful purposes of interfering with impoundment operations, obstructing execution of federal court orders, and using force and violence against federal law enforcement officers while they were performing their duties.
b. Used the internet and other facilities in interstate commerce to knowingly broadcast false, deceitful, and deceptive images and messages for the purpose of recruiting Followers.
c. Used the internet and other facilities in interstate commerce to encourage, counsel, and incite Followers to bring guns to Bundy Ranch for the unlawful purposes of interfering with impoundment operations, obstructing the execution of federal court orders, and using force and violence against federal law enforcement officers to prevent them from discharging their duties.
d. Traveled in interstate commerce and used other facilities in interstate commerce to threaten force, violence, and economic harm to contractors providing services to the BLM during impoundment operations.
e. Threatened and used force and violence against BLM civilian employees engaged in impoundment operations for the purpose of obstructing the execution of federal court orders and interfering with impoundment operations.
f. Counseled, incited, and led Followers to use, carry, brandish, and aim firearms, including assault rifles, for the purpose of assaulting federal law enforcement officers.
g. Counseled, incited, and led Followers to use, carry, brandish, and aim firearms, including assault rifles, for the purpose of extorting federal law enforcement officers.
h. Organized Followers into body guards, armed patrols, and security checkpoints for the purpose of using threats, force, violence, and intimidation to protect the conspirators, prevent law enforcement actions against the conspirators, prevent the execution of federal court orders, and prevent law enforcement officers from discharging their duties.
c. Roles of the Conspirators.
43. BUNDY was the leader, orgamzer, and chief beneficiary of the conspiracy, possessing ultimate authority over the scope, manner, and means of conspiratorial operations and receiving the economic benefits of the extortion.
44. BUNDY and Co-Conspirators 1, 2, 3, and 4 were leaders organizers of the conspiracy who, among other things: recruited Followers; interfered with impoundment operations through threats and use of force and violence; interfered with impoundment operations by attempting to extort BLM contractors; led an armed assault against federal law enforcement officers; delivered extortionate demands to law enforcement officers; and extorted federal law enforcement officers. Co-Conspirators 1, 2, 3, and 4 have been arrested and are detained on federal charges lodged in another district.
D. Overt Acts in Furtherance of the Conspiracy.
49. It was a part of the conspiracy that from March 28 to April 11, 2014, and for the purpose of carrying out the objects of the conspiracy, BUNDY and his co-conspirators performed, or caused to be performed, the following overt acts, among many others.
1. March 28 to April 11: The Conspirators Interfered with
Impoundment Operations and Used Deceit and Deception to
Recruit Followers.
50. On or about March 28, 2014, BUNDY and others working with him, blocked a convoy of vehicles carrying horses and equipment intended for use in impoundment operations, confronting and threatening civilian contractors, endangering the safety of the personnel m the convoy, and interfering with impoundment operations.
51. Shortly thereafter, and in an effort to recruit Followers, BUNDY caused the broadcast of a video of the confrontation with the contractors entitled "Range War," depicting images captured during the confrontation, combining the with false, deceitful and deceptive statements to the effect that the BLM was stealing BUNDYs cattle.
52. On or about April 2, 2014, Co-conspirator 1 traveled from Nevada to Utah to threaten force, violence, and economic harm to the contract auctioneer providing services to the BLM, by, among other things, entering upon the contractor's property for the purpose of interfering with business operations, threatening and intimidating customers and employees, interfering with business operations, and threatening to shut down the business if the contractor fulfilled his contractual obligations with BLM.
53. On or about April 5, 2014, BUNDY threatened force and violence against federal law enforcement officers by publically stating, among other things: "I've done quite a bit so far to keep my cattle, but I guess it's not been enough ... they took 75 of my cattle today ... I have said I'd do what it takes to keep my cattle
so I guess it is going to have to be more physical."
54. On or about April 6, 2014, co-conspirator 1 and another conspirator interfered with impoundment operations by positioning themselves to block a BLM convoy and refusing to leave the area when asked to do so. Failing to leave after repeated requests, a co-conspirator was arrested by law enforcement officers.
55. Shortly thereafter, BUNDY caused images of the arrest to be broadcasted over the internet, combining them with false, deceitful and deceptive statements to the effect that the BLM supposedly: employed snipers against Bundy family members; used excessive force during the arrest; and arrested a conspirator for exercising his First Amendment rights.
56. On or about April 7, 2014, Co-conspirator 2 traveled from Arizona to the Bundy Ranch in Nevada.
57. On or about April 7, 2014, Co-conspirator 3 in Montana, contacted BUNDY in Nevada, by telephone.
58. On or about April 7, 2014, Co-conspirator 3, who referred to himself a leader of a network he referred to as Operation Mutual Aid ("OMA"), used the internet and other facilities in interstate commerce to recruit others whom Co-conspirator 3 referred to as "militia" belonging to the OMA network. Attempting to incite the so-called OMA "militia" members to travel to Bundy Ranch for unlawful purposes, Co-conspirator 3 falsely, deceptively, and deceitfully stated, among other things, that the ranch was surrounded by BLM snipers, the Bundy family was isolated, and BLM wanted BUNDY dead.
59. On or about April 7, 2014, BUNDY and others working with him established a site only minutes travel distance from the Bundy Ranch along Nevada State Route 170, a state road that also served as the main route between the Impoundment Site and the public land where impoundment operations were taking place. Strategically located between the Impoundment Site and various ingress and egress points to public land, the location of the site served as both a natural vantage point from which to observe impoundment operations and a potential choke-point for disrupting BLM convoys. Conspicuous for, among other things, a stage and two tall flagpoles, one of which flew the Nevada State flag above the flag of the United States, this site (hereinafter referred to as "the Staging Site") served as a base of operations from which the conspirators made speeches, received and organize Followers as they arrived at Bundy Ranch, and gathered and organized Follower before initiating their assaults on federal law enforcement officers.
60. On or about April 8, 2014, Co-conspirator 4 in California, contacted
BUNDY in Nevada, by telephone.
61. On or about April 8, 2014, Co-conspirator 4 and BUNDY broadcasted messages over the internet. Using deceit, deception, and threats to incite others to travel to Bundy Ranch for unlawful purposes, BUNDY told listeners, among other things, that: "they have my house surrounded ... the federal government is stealing my property ... [the BLM] are armed with assault rifles ... they have snipers ... haven't called no militia but, hey, that looks like where we are ... there is a strong army out here ... we are going to have to take our land back ... somebody is going to have to back off ... we the people will put our boots down and walk over these people ... they are up against a man who will do whatever it takes."
62. In that same broadcast, Co-conspirator 4 used threats to incite listeners to travel to Bundy Ranch for unlawful purposes, telling listeners, among other things, that: "if this is not the issue right now where we stand and fight to the absolute death there is no other option; the federal government must get out of the State of Nevada ... if they don't want it to be peaceful it is by their choice ... I'm calling on all Americans anywhere in the vicinity of Clark County, Nevada ... if you're in Nevada and can legally carry, get weapons out there, o.k .... we are going to stand and fight in Clark County, Nevada ... they will leave or else."
63. On or about April 8, 2014, Co-conspirator 3 sent a message from Montana to Pennsylvania to another person who referred to himself as one of the leaders in OMA, stating, among other things, that it was "time to invite everyone to the first annual Patriots (sic) Picnic at the Bundy Ranch" and telling the 0MA leader that the Bundys "still want help."
64. On or about April 8, 2014, and for the purpose of recruiting Followers, Co-Conspirator 3 sent a message over the internet, stating that Co-Conspirator 3 had spoken with BUNDY and that "he knows we're coming and has opened his Iand up to everyone willing ... OMA is moving ... not going public with this until more
are enroute."
65. On or about April 8, 2014, Co-conspirator 3 caused an email to be sent to OMA members stating: "we have made the decision to mobilize in Nevada, unit are underway as I type this ... the feds arrested some protestors today, and the words 'we need you now' were uttered ... we have approximately 150 responding, but that number is [gr]owing by the hour." The message provided directions an
grid coordinates to Bundy Ranch.
66. On or about and between April 8 and 9, 2014, Co-conspirator 4 traveled from California to Bundy Ranch in Nevada.
67. On or about and between April 8 and 9, 2014, Co-conspirator traveled from Montana to Bundy Ranch in Nevada.
68. On or about April 9, 2014, Co-conspirators 3 and 4 met with BUNDY and other conspirators at Bundy Ranch.
69. On the morning of April 9, 2014, Co-conspirator 4 met with the SAC and stated that he was acting as a liaison between Bundy Followers and the BLM. Threatening the SAC, Co-conspirator 4 stated: "What are you guys going to do if 10,000 people show up? ... Are you prepared for this? ... I don't believe in firing single bullet unless in absolute defense and it's legal and constitutional."
70. On or about April 9, 2014, and for the purpose of inciting others to travel to Bundy Ranch for an unlawful purpose, the conspirators caused a message to be broadcasted over the internet, stating: "The Bundy family has requested help from militia groups including Operation Mutual Aid, 3 Percenters club, freedom fighters, and other operations to come and stand with us and regain our rights and freedom."
71. On April 9, 2014, and for the purpose of inciting others to travel to Bundy Ranch for an unlawful purpose, Co-conspirator 4 broadcasted a message over the internet, stating, among other things: "the BLM knows if they are outnumbered and outgunned ... they will stand down ... we want BLM to get out of the state of
Nevada ... I fully expect the standoff will occur when thousands go to repossess the rightfully owned property of the Bundys ... we need strength in numbers."
72. On or about April 9, 2014, Co-conspirator 1, and others working with him, traveled for a second time from Nevada to Utah to threaten force, violence, and
economic loss to the contract auctioneer providing services to the BLM by, among
other things: intimidating customers; interfering with business operations; and instilling fear and apprehension in customers and employees.
73. On or about April 9, 2014, and for the purpose of inciting others to travel to Bundy Ranch for an unlawful purpose, Co-conspirator 4 broadcasted message over the internet, stating, among other things: "now is the time to show up for something like this ... we need ten thousand people to come here ... I only have
one fear is that people that don't respond to this call ... it's time to make a stand
against tyranny ... we need to let everyone know that BLM has zero authority."
74. On April 9, 2014, Co-conspirators 2 and 4 assaulted federal officers by, among other things: intercepting and blocking a convoy of BLM vehicles engaged in
impoundment operations; colliding an ATV into a truck in the convoy in order t
stall the truck and gain entry by force; attempting to forcibly gain entrance to the
stalled truck; attempting to throw a rock at law enforcement officers while the
officers were protecting the truck and the civilian passengers inside; threatening physical harm to law enforcement officers while they were protecting the truck and the civilian passengers inside; and causing physical contact with an officer while the officer was engaged in protecting the truck and the civilian passengers inside.
75. On or about April 9, 2014, and for the purpose of inciting others to travel to Bundy Ranch for an unlawful purpose, Co-Conspirator 4 broadcasted message over the internet, stating, among other things: "we were serious about stopping the convoy ... [the BLM] were caught off guard and tried to push past us ... they couldn't do it ... we outnumbered them and they retreated ... we know how they will come back after they retreat ... my biggest fear is if we don't respond ... they retreated and will come back with a bigger force ... we need to disperse them with tens of thousands ... we want BLM to always retreat because we will always outnumber them ... we have all been waiting for that ultimate moment ... there is so much at stake ... we can win with numbers ... I've got people coming from Michigan ... militia members who are fully armed are here ... it's good to watch the BLM with its tail between its legs . . . get out here . . . this is going to get exciting ... ultimately get the feds to leave."
76. On April 10, 2014, and for the purpose of inciting others to travel to Bundy Ranch for an unlawful purpose, Co-conspirator 3 caused an email to be sent to self-described "militia" members of OMA under the subject line "Bundy Objectives," as follows:
Nevada Alert! We are requesting help to distribute the following to
any and all media, blog, patriot groups etc.
1. Secure the Bundy family from government incursion which includes protection of all personnel responding in support of the Bundys i.e. Protestors, extended family, and friends.
2. To return the confiscated Clark County Nevada property currently blocke4 by federal personnel to it's (sic) rightful stewards, the people of Clark County, Nevada.
3. To secure and return to Mr. Bundys (sic) ranch the mounting number of cattle which have been confiscated by BLM agents and private contractors.
These objectives are in cohesion with Cliven Bundy and the Bundy
ranch ....
77. On or about April 10, 2014, and for the purpose of inciting others to travel to Bundy Ranch for an unlawful purpose, Co-conspirator 4 broadcasted message over the internet, stating, among other things: "there is not enough militia here ... we have 1OOO's of very organized constitutional militia ... they are trickling in ... where we will fail is for us not to at least match the overwhelming
force . . . we have about 50 members here now ... where we will fail is for us not to not match the BLM force ... we need a show of force ... we did a recon and found that BLM have hundreds of vehicles . . BLM needs to vacate immediately ... we need the numbers for the feds to leave . . they will come back with a bigger force ... we need tens of thousands of people so they retreat ... come out here ... we've a been waiting for the ultimate moment ... we can win with numbers ... get out here no matter where you are ... militia members here are fully armed."
78. On or about April 10, 2014, and for the purpose of inciting other to travel to Bundy Ranch for an unlawful purpose, Co-conspirator 4 broadcasted message over the internet, stating, among other things: "there is a court order, but the court is corrupt . . . BLM believes they are acting constitutionally . . . BLM is in violation of every God-given right of every human being ... [BLM's] closure order are 'shelter in place' ... [BLM] aimed AR-15's at me [during confrontation on April
9] . . . Waco and Ruby Ridge was a show of force by government and violate sovereign rights ... if we have 10,000 people, [the BLM] will have to get past us."
79. On the morning of April 11, 2014, Co-Conspirator 4 met with the SAC and stated, among other things: "we are going to have a face-to-face confrontation ... we have thousands of people . . . we are going to come here and it is non negotiable ... if that comes about, we want to make sure that any [BLM officer]
who wants to stand down will not be retaliated against . . . this is non negotiable ... if you make the decision to go face-to-face and someone gets hurt we are going to hold you responsible . . . tell D.C. that the justification for this is from a corrupt court . . . I'm relaying a message ... if anyone is acting unconstitutionally they will be arrested ... I came here to allow you to prevent a scenario where someone get hurt."
80. By on or about April 11, 2014, hundreds of Followers traveled to Nevada, many armed with assault rifles and other firearms and many of who identified themselves as "militia" and wore military style clothing and equipment.
81. By on or about April 11, 2014, Co-conspirator 3 and others working
with him, received the armed Followers, including those who identified themselves as "militia." The leaders of the conspiracy placed them into camps, which the leaders described as "militia camps," from which camps the conspirators would organize and deploy the militia and other armed Followers.
82. By on or about April 11, 2014, Co-conspirator 3, and others working with him, organized armed Followers and militia into patrols and armed checkpoints to provide security to the conspirators and their criminal enterprise.
2. April 12: The Conspirators Assaulted and Extorted Law Enforcement Officers.
83. It was further a part of the conspiracy that on April 12, 2014, BUNDY and his co-conspirators, organized, led and executed a mass assault on federal la
enforcement officers in order to obtain the seized cattle, as follows.
84. By the morning of April 12, the BLM had seized approximately 400 head of cattle and had them corralled at the Impoundment Site, awaiting further shipment out of the state of Nevada.
85. On the morning of April 12, BUNDY led a rally of hundreds of his Followers, including militia and other armed Followers, at the Rally Site where he told them that "God [is] going to be with us" and that it was time "to take our land back." He then commanded his Followers to get the cattle.
86. BUNDY directed his Followers that "horse people" (Followers ridinghorses) would leave the Rally Site and travel a dirt road to the Toquop wash, the location of the Impoundment Site, a distance of about 3.5 miles. While that was
happening, so commanded BUNDY, the other Followers, including militia and
other armed Followers, were to travel the highway by vehicle, a distance of about 5 miles, and "shut down the freeway" at the Impoundment Site. The Followers, as directed BUNDY, were then to meet with the "horse people" in the Toquop wash.
87. The Followers did as BUNDY ordered. Armed with their weapons, the Followers hurriedly loaded themselves into cars and trucks and moved en masse to
the Impoundment Site, jamming the roads and slowing traffic on northbound I-15 to a trickle, making it difficult for state and local law enforcement vehicles to respond. When the Followers arrived at the Impoundment Site, they jumped out of their vehicles and many of them moved quickly on foot to a position across from the main entrance.
88. Other Followers took positions on the bridges overlooking the Impoundment Site. The few local law enforcement officers who were able to respond formed a human line in the I-15 median to block the Followers, many of whom carried and brandished assault rifles, from entering at the main entrance to the Impoundment Site.
89. Many Followers then moved a few hundred yards east and below the main entrance and met Co-conspirator 2 in the Toquop wash, gathering about 15
yards opposite from a makeshift metal rail gate that blocked the wash entrance
beneath the southbound bridge of I-15.
90. By 12:00 noon, over 400 of BUNDY's Followers had converged upon the Impoundment Site, many of the Followers were comprised of Bundy's militia openly brandishing assault rifles, others bearing side arms, the combined group grossly outnumbering the officers that protected the site. About 60 yards across
from the metal rail gate at the wash entrance to the site, between the north an
southbound I-15 bridges, a crowd of more than 270 Followers ~ a combination o
militia and non-militia on foot and about 40 men and women on horseback - formed into a line along the bottom of the wash about 60 yards across. This position was guarded by about 50 federal law enforcement officers, positioned beginning about 10 to 20 yards behind the gate.
91. The officers at the gate were dangerously exposed. They were in the open on low ground at the bottom of the wash, below highway bridges that towered more than 40 feet above them and surrounded on the sides by steep embankment of high ground. The terrain acted like a funnel with them at the bottom and no natural cover or concealment to protect them from the gunmen on the high ground, their only protection being their body armor and the vehicles they happened to drive to the gate. At this point approximately 40 Followers were either carrying or brandishing firearms in front of the officers, many of them moving in and out of the line, taking high ground on the sides of the wash. Meanwhile, more than 200 Followers carried or brandished firearms while on the bridges that towered more than 40 feet above the officers, some of them aiming assault rifles at the officers from covered and concealed sniper positions.
92. The officers guarding the gate could readily observe gunmen bobbing up and down from behind the concrete barriers that bordered the northbound I-15 bridge, indicating to the officers that the gunmen were acquiring, and determining
the range to, their officer-targets. The officers could also observe armed gunmen
dressed in military-style tactical gear and wearing body armor, moving in and among the unarmed Followers, using them as human shields to mask their movements while still others took tactically superior positions on the sides of the
wash.
93. The Followers' close proximity to the officers, their array and formation in the wash, their refusal to disperse upon command, their angry taunts, their numbers carrying or brandishing firearms, their movement to the gate while brandishing assault rifles and wearing body armor, and their superior sniper positions on the bridge above, all caused the officers to fear immediate bodily harm or death.
94. Around 12: 15, the Followers in the wash, led by Co-conspirator 2, advanced to the gate. The gunmen moved with him, openly brandishing their rifle and taking over-watch positions on the high ground within full view of the tactically
disadvantaged officers, the snipers in concealed positions on and under the bridge
now aiming their assault rifles at the officers. Seeing the combined force arrayed
against them - an organized crowd of more than 400, more than 60 among the crowd carrying or brandishing rifles or pistols, 40 supporters on horseback, militia snipers concealed on the bridges above them with their rifles zeroed-in on the
officers, militia gunmen intermingled with the crowd using the unarmed people t
shield their movement, militia gunmen in over-watch positions on the high ground
the officers believed they were going to be shot and killed. They were stymied
prevented from shooting the gunmen who posed such an obvious threat to their lives out of concern they would spark a firefight that would kill or injure unarmed
people. Unable to surgically remove the deadly threats before them, outnumbered, outgunned, and located in a dangerously exposed and tactically inferior position, the officers knew they were easy targets. They still held their ground.
95. Upon reaching the gate and backed by his gunmen and snipers, Coconspirator
2 told the SAC that he and the rest of his force would not leave until the BLM left the impoundment site. When asked to move his gun-backed crowd away from the gate so the officers could disengage, Co-conspirator 2 refused and demanded that the officers leave first stating, among other things, ''You need to leave ... that's the terms ... no, you need to leave ... you are on Nevada State property ... the time is now ... no, the time is now."
96. To prevent the disaster that was sure to follow if they remained longer, the SAC was forced to give in to Co-conspirator 2's demands and ordered his officer to leave, abandoning the post, the impoundment site, and the cattle to BUNDY.
97. Having made the decision to meet the conspirators' demands, the SAC met with Co-conspirator 1 near the main entrance to the Impoundment Site to negotiate the departure of the law enforcement officers. While the armed Followers held their position below at the wash entrance, Co-conspirator 1 demanded that the BLM officers pack all of the equipment and leave the Impoundment Site within two hours.
98. The law enforcement officers were forced to abandon the Impoundment Site and the cattle to the conspirators and their Followers, who promptly release and returned them to BUNDY and took down the fences comprising the corrals.
3. Continuing Conspiracy - Post-Assault: The Conspirator Organized Bodyguards, Patrols and Checkpoints to Prevent and Deter Future Law Enforcement Actions.
99. It was further a part of the conspiracy that following the April 1 assault and extortion, BUNDY and the co-conspirators took such other actions a necessary to protect themselves and their ill-gotten gains and to further interfere with and prevent future federal law enforcement actions on the public lands.
100. From April 12 to at least the end of May 2014, the BUDNY and the coconspirators established, organized, and maintained militia camps to provide housing and logistical support to armed gunmen who continued to travel to the
Bundy Ranch.
101. From April 12 to at least the end of May 2014, BUNDY and his co conspirators established armed checkpoints and security patrols to prevent and deter law enforcement actions against the conspirators, including recovering the extorted cattle.
102. From April 12, 2014 through September 2014, Co-Conspirator 4 made statements to the SAC, threatening similar assaultive conduct in the event the
BLM attempted further law enforcement actions.
103. From April 12, 2014 through the date of this Complaint, BUNDY made public statements threatening that he would continue to interfere with federal law enforcement actions against him or the cattle.
104. From April 12, 2014 through the date of this Complaint, BUNDY continued to employ body guards to protect him and other co-conspirators fro
federal law enforcement actions.
105. From April 12, 2014, through the date of this Complaint, the BUNDY and his co-conspirators continue to take such actions as necessary to hold, protect, and prevent the impoundment of the extorted cattle and such other trespass cattle that are subject to the 2013 Court Orders.
s__________
Joel P WIllis
Federal Bureau of Investigation
Subscribed and Sworn to before this 11th day of February, 2016.
s__________
Peggy A. Leen
United States Magistrate Judge
-
- Grand Master Consul of Quatloosia
- Posts: 830
- Joined: Tue Jul 01, 2003 3:19 am
- Location: Seattle
Re: Sovrun Cattle - The Sagebrush Saga of Cliven Bundy
What does Cliven Bundy Owe BLM and the US?
For those who have accepted permits, the current BLM rate for grazing in Nevada is $5.12/AUM. If Bundy had accepted the permits, for his herd of roughly 1,000 cattle, he would have paid $5,120/month or $61,440 /year in 2015. (His herd was smaller and rates were lower in earlier years.) He probably would have owed less than $1 million dollars had he accepted and paid for the ephemeral grazing permits.
The 2015 rate for willful unauthorized grazing rate is $34.50/AUM. This would result in fees for 1,000 head of cattle of $34,500/month or $414,000/year. (Again the herd was smaller and the rates were lower in prior years.) Under any scenario the unauthorized grazing (willful) rates will vastly exceed $1 million, and will probably be closer to $4 million or $5 million.
http://www.blm.gov/wo/st/en/info/regula ... 5-056.html
In November of 1998, the district court also ordered Bundy to pay damages of $200 per head of cattle per day for any cattle remaining on the Allotment. Assuming an average herd size of 400 cattle, Bundy owes the United States (400 x $200 x 365 x 17) $496,400,000. While these damages were intended to function like civil contempt and force Bundy to remove his cattle, they had no effect.
For those who have accepted permits, the current BLM rate for grazing in Nevada is $5.12/AUM. If Bundy had accepted the permits, for his herd of roughly 1,000 cattle, he would have paid $5,120/month or $61,440 /year in 2015. (His herd was smaller and rates were lower in earlier years.) He probably would have owed less than $1 million dollars had he accepted and paid for the ephemeral grazing permits.
The 2015 rate for willful unauthorized grazing rate is $34.50/AUM. This would result in fees for 1,000 head of cattle of $34,500/month or $414,000/year. (Again the herd was smaller and the rates were lower in prior years.) Under any scenario the unauthorized grazing (willful) rates will vastly exceed $1 million, and will probably be closer to $4 million or $5 million.
http://www.blm.gov/wo/st/en/info/regula ... 5-056.html
In November of 1998, the district court also ordered Bundy to pay damages of $200 per head of cattle per day for any cattle remaining on the Allotment. Assuming an average herd size of 400 cattle, Bundy owes the United States (400 x $200 x 365 x 17) $496,400,000. While these damages were intended to function like civil contempt and force Bundy to remove his cattle, they had no effect.
-
- Admiral of the Quatloosian Seas
- Posts: 356
- Joined: Sat May 22, 2010 4:58 pm
Re: Sovrun Cattle - The Sagebrush Saga of Cliven Bundy
From Demo's twitter:jcolvin2 wrote:Cliven Bundy Criminal Complaint (filed 2/11/2016):
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF NEVADA
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
Plaintiff,
v.
CLIVEN D. BUNDY,
Defendant.
)
)
) CRIMINAL COMPLAINT
)
) Case No.: 2:16-mj-00127-PAL
) VIOLATIONS:
)
) 18 U.S.C. § 371 - Conspiracy to Commit
) An Offense Against the United States;
)
) 18 U.S.C. § lll(b) -Assault on a Federal
) Law Enforcement Officer;
)
) 18 U.S.C. § 924(c) - Use and Carry of a
) Firearm In Relation to a Crime of
) Violence;
)
) 18 U.S.C. § 1503 - Obstruction of the
) Administration of Justice;
)
) 18 U.S.C. § 1951 - Interference with
) Commerce by Extortion;
)
) 18 U.S.C. § 2 -Aiding and Abetting
BEFORE the United States Magistrate Judge, Las Vegas, Nevada, Joel P.
Willis, Special Agent, Federal Bureau of Investigation, Complainant herein, bein
first duly sworn deposes and states as follows:
<Snip>
s__________
Joel P WIllis
Federal Bureau of Investigation
Subscribed and Sworn to before this 11th day of February, 2016.
s__________
Peggy A. Leen
United States Magistrate Judge
JJ MacNab @jjmacnab 2h2 hours ago
Unnamed Conspirators:
#1 Ryan Bundy
#2 Ammon Bundy
#3 Ryan Payne
#4 Pete Santilli
-
- Further Moderator
- Posts: 7559
- Joined: Thu Feb 06, 2003 11:48 pm
- Location: Virgin Islands Gunsmith
Re: Sovrun Cattle - The Sagebrush Saga of Cliven Bundy
This should prove to those who thought that the government was "coddling" or giving special treatment to Bundy and Co. that was not the case. Cliven has effectively lost everything at this point. Whatever he truly owns will end up being attached by federal judgments.
The government may move slow, but when it finally gets there, it is going to hurt.
The government may move slow, but when it finally gets there, it is going to hurt.
"I could be dead wrong on this" - Irwin Schiff
"Do you realize I may even be delusional with respect to my income tax beliefs? " - Irwin Schiff
"Do you realize I may even be delusional with respect to my income tax beliefs? " - Irwin Schiff
-
- Slavering Minister of Auto-erotic Insinuation
- Posts: 3759
- Joined: Thu Sep 30, 2010 9:35 am
- Location: Quatloos Immigration Control
Re: Sovrun Cattle - The Sagebrush Saga of Cliven Bundy
If it ever sinks into the brain of old man Bundy as to what has happened, he is going to have to be on suicide watch. If he ever gets out of jail his ranch will have long gone and he'll likely still only be able to see some of his sons during visiting hours.
"There is something about true madness that goes beyond mere eccentricity." Will Self
-
- A Balthazar of Quatloosian Truth
- Posts: 13806
- Joined: Mon Jul 04, 2005 7:17 pm
Re: Sovrun Cattle - The Sagebrush Saga of Cliven Bundy
I don't pretend to understand the Federal Criminal process, BUT, my understanding is that they can't as a rule go to court for trial on a complaint, they have to get an actual indictment to proceed, and again my understanding is that this is just a placeholder to keep the old fraud locked up until they can get a complete indictment to take to trial. I personally would expect the actual indictment to be considerable longer include a number of other things. I think he is effectively looking at an effective life sentence one way or the other, as possibly are his "boys".
I also don't feel the least bit of sympathy either, and what will now befall his family(s) is entirely at his own making.
I also don't feel the least bit of sympathy either, and what will now befall his family(s) is entirely at his own making.
The fact that you sincerely and wholeheartedly believe that the “Law of Gravity” is unconstitutional and a violation of your sovereign rights, does not absolve you of adherence to it.
-
- Knight Templar of the Sacred Tax
- Posts: 7668
- Joined: Sat May 19, 2007 12:59 pm
- Location: Texas
Re: Sovrun Cattle - The Sagebrush Saga of Cliven Bundy
Excerpt from Rule 7 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure:notorial dissent wrote:...my understanding is that they can't as a rule go to court for trial on a complaint, they have to get an actual indictment to proceed, and again my understanding is that this is just a placeholder to keep the old fraud locked up until they can get a complete indictment to take to trial....
Excerpt from Rule 58(b)(1):Rule 7. The Indictment and the Information
(a) When Used.
(1) Felony. An offense (other than criminal contempt) must be prosecuted by an indictment if it is punishable:
(A) by death; or
(B) by imprisonment for more than one year.
(2) Misdemeanor. An offense punishable by imprisonment for one year or less may be prosecuted in accordance with Rule 58(b)(1).
(b) Waiving Indictment. An offense punishable by imprisonment for more than one year may be prosecuted by information if the defendant—in open court and after being advised of the nature of the charge and of the defendant’s rights—waives prosecution by indictment.....
.....Charging Document. The trial of a misdemeanor may proceed on an indictment, information, or complaint. The trial of a petty offense may also proceed on a citation or violation notice.
"My greatest fear is that the audience will beat me to the punch line." -- David Mamet
-
- A Balthazar of Quatloosian Truth
- Posts: 13806
- Joined: Mon Jul 04, 2005 7:17 pm
Re: Sovrun Cattle - The Sagebrush Saga of Cliven Bundy
That is all true, however, I don't think ANY of the charges in question are for less than a year, or any of the other excepts, so I didn't really see any of the excepts applying, and I really can't see any of this bunch accepting the easy way and will insist on a full indictment, which I have no doubt they will ultimately get.
The fact that you sincerely and wholeheartedly believe that the “Law of Gravity” is unconstitutional and a violation of your sovereign rights, does not absolve you of adherence to it.
-
- Admiral of the Quatloosian Seas
- Posts: 3076
- Joined: Tue Aug 20, 2013 1:16 am
-
- Grand Master Consul of Quatloosia
- Posts: 830
- Joined: Tue Jul 01, 2003 3:19 am
- Location: Seattle
Re: Sovrun Cattle - The Sagebrush Saga of Cliven Bundy
On February 16, 2016, Cliven Bundy was ordered detained pending trial:
"A U.S. judge ordered Nevada rancher Cliven Bundy to stay in jail until he is taken back to Nevada to face charges stemming from a 2014 standoff with federal officials near his ranch.
"U.S. Magistrate Judge Janice Stewart ruled Tuesday that Bundy shouldn't be released ahead of trial because 'that is likely the last the government will see of him.'"
http://www.kgw.com/news/crime/cliven-bu ... y/44882958
The government submission arguing for detention:
https://www.scribd.com/doc/299478603/Cl ... nts-Feb-16
"A U.S. judge ordered Nevada rancher Cliven Bundy to stay in jail until he is taken back to Nevada to face charges stemming from a 2014 standoff with federal officials near his ranch.
"U.S. Magistrate Judge Janice Stewart ruled Tuesday that Bundy shouldn't be released ahead of trial because 'that is likely the last the government will see of him.'"
http://www.kgw.com/news/crime/cliven-bu ... y/44882958
The government submission arguing for detention:
https://www.scribd.com/doc/299478603/Cl ... nts-Feb-16
-
- A Balthazar of Quatloosian Truth
- Posts: 13806
- Joined: Mon Jul 04, 2005 7:17 pm
Re: Sovrun Cattle - The Sagebrush Saga of Cliven Bundy
The govt's submission makes very entertaining reading, and is somewhat less than subtle about it.
Basically, barring something untoward in NV, Cliven has reached his new home.
Basically, barring something untoward in NV, Cliven has reached his new home.
The fact that you sincerely and wholeheartedly believe that the “Law of Gravity” is unconstitutional and a violation of your sovereign rights, does not absolve you of adherence to it.
-
- Knight Templar of the Sacred Tax
- Posts: 7668
- Joined: Sat May 19, 2007 12:59 pm
- Location: Texas
Re: Sovrun Cattle - The Sagebrush Saga of Cliven Bundy
With respect to guilt or innocence of Mr. Cliven Bundy, I'll withhold a conclusion until I see how the case against him turns out.
With respect to the decision to hold him in jail while he is awaiting trial, Mr. Bundy -- because of his own behavior -- has only himself to blame for his situation.
"What goes around comes around."
With respect to the decision to hold him in jail while he is awaiting trial, Mr. Bundy -- because of his own behavior -- has only himself to blame for his situation.
"What goes around comes around."
"My greatest fear is that the audience will beat me to the punch line." -- David Mamet
-
- Further Moderator
- Posts: 7559
- Joined: Thu Feb 06, 2003 11:48 pm
- Location: Virgin Islands Gunsmith
Re: Sovrun Cattle - The Sagebrush Saga of Cliven Bundy
Indeed. He set himself up for this situation by taking a posture of threatening violence. The judge saw what obviously would transpire if Cliven was released on bail or his own recognizance, mainly Cliven beating a hasty retreat to Bunkerville and then screaming for the militias to surround his ranch and hold off the federales. Of course, this also raises the question of what Cliven was doing since the BLM standoff: was he staying at home all of that time only because he knew or guessed that the feds would pick him up in a heartbeat?Famspear wrote:With respect to the decision to hold him in jail while he is awaiting trial, Mr. Bundy -- because of his own behavior -- has only himself to blame for his situation.
"What goes around comes around."
"I could be dead wrong on this" - Irwin Schiff
"Do you realize I may even be delusional with respect to my income tax beliefs? " - Irwin Schiff
"Do you realize I may even be delusional with respect to my income tax beliefs? " - Irwin Schiff
-
- Admiral of the Quatloosian Seas
- Posts: 3076
- Joined: Tue Aug 20, 2013 1:16 am
Re: Sovrun Cattle - The Sagebrush Saga of Cliven Bundy
Meanwhile:
http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016 ... -artifactsThe Oregon standoff is over but militia left something on the refuge: their poop
http://www.cbsnews.com/news/oregon-mili ... t-of-poop/Oregon militia left firearms, bombs and a lot of poop
-
- Supreme Prophet (Junior Division)
- Posts: 6138
- Joined: Thu Apr 23, 2009 8:26 pm
- Location: In the woods, with a Hudson Bay axe in my hands.
Re: Sovrun Cattle - The Sagebrush Saga of Cliven Bundy
Never fear, Yeehawdists. Shawna Cox is charging to your rescue:
http://www.scribd.com/doc/299588918/2-1 ... -Complaint
I wish that I had a dollar for every colossally stupid pseudolegal claim and every grammatical and spelling error in this screed.
http://www.scribd.com/doc/299588918/2-1 ... -Complaint
I wish that I had a dollar for every colossally stupid pseudolegal claim and every grammatical and spelling error in this screed.
"We've been attacked by the intelligent, educated segment of the culture." -- Pastor Ray Mummert, Dover, PA, during an attempt to introduce creationism -- er, "intelligent design", into the Dover Public Schools