UK DD clawbacks and Simon Goldberg
Moderator: ArthurWankspittle
-
- Admiral of the Quatloosian Seas
- Posts: 1581
- Joined: Thu Jun 19, 2014 7:11 pm
- Location: In a gallery, with Peanuts.
Re: UK DD clawbacks and Simon Goldberg
I would also suggest that the size of the amount is just large enough for the police to want to take an interest. It seems like a serious attempt at fraud. After all the shopkeeper who was jailed, which was pointed out earlier in this thread, only clawed back £20k.
If the Police do take an interest in this matter, then even paying back the money may not be enough to stave off conviction and imprisonment.
If the Police do take an interest in this matter, then even paying back the money may not be enough to stave off conviction and imprisonment.
Warning may contain traces of nut
-
- Stern Faced Schoolmaster of Serious Discussion
- Posts: 1363
- Joined: Wed Oct 29, 2014 7:12 am
- Location: England, UK
Re: UK DD clawbacks and Simon Goldberg
It would be the ultimate get-into-debt-free success: GOOFer tries to claim back mortgage payments, hoping to keep both money and house; instead GOOFer loses money and/or house and/or liberty.
-
- Admiral of the Quatloosian Seas
- Posts: 2186
- Joined: Sat Oct 25, 2014 9:58 pm
Re: UK DD clawbacks and Simon Goldberg
It's impossible to have any sympathy for someone who thought he could defraud £26,000, and then if the victims didn't complain about it quickly enough he could legally keep their money.murphy75 wrote:My understanding is that they had 10 days to re-butt my claim so how can they write to me 5 months later with this demand?
Hopefully just the start of a long and stressful journey, which will end with his house being seized and sold to pay back what he owes. The best he can pray for is that they allow him to pay it back gradually, with appropriate interest added.murphy75 wrote:Also Nationwide building society have froze my account and it is being dealt with by the special investigation department...
"don't be hubris ever..." Steve Mccrae, noted legal ExpertInFuckAll.
-
- A Balthazar of Quatloosian Truth
- Posts: 13806
- Joined: Mon Jul 04, 2005 7:17 pm
Re: UK DD clawbacks and Simon Goldberg
The system you have in place there must be vastly different than the one we use here. I used to investigate low level VISA claims, and we of course had some far bigger than this, but we never would have just reversed something like this out of hand.
On something like that mortgage reversal I can't begin to imagine that we'd have reversed anything like £26,000, without suspecting fraud, in this case on the part of the cardholder.
I can see them getting away with this on small items, happens all the time, but utility bills and mortgage payments, just doesn't make sense. and what it does come down to is fraud once it is done, not maybe, but felony fraud, and we, and whoever they defrauded would have pressed charges. Frozen bank accounts would have been the least of their problems.
On something like that mortgage reversal I can't begin to imagine that we'd have reversed anything like £26,000, without suspecting fraud, in this case on the part of the cardholder.
I can see them getting away with this on small items, happens all the time, but utility bills and mortgage payments, just doesn't make sense. and what it does come down to is fraud once it is done, not maybe, but felony fraud, and we, and whoever they defrauded would have pressed charges. Frozen bank accounts would have been the least of their problems.
The fact that you sincerely and wholeheartedly believe that the “Law of Gravity” is unconstitutional and a violation of your sovereign rights, does not absolve you of adherence to it.
-
- Admiral of the Quatloosian Seas
- Posts: 1186
- Joined: Sun Feb 08, 2015 2:47 pm
- Location: Manchester by day, Slaithwaite by night
Re: UK DD clawbacks and Simon Goldberg
Looks as if things might have escalated for poor old GOOFY murph75.
http://getoutofdebtfree.org/forum/viewt ... 49#p376558
http://getoutofdebtfree.org/forum/viewt ... 49#p376558
-
- Admiral of the Quatloosian Seas
- Posts: 764
- Joined: Sat Mar 28, 2015 10:18 am
Re: UK DD clawbacks and Simon Goldberg
Good serve the RatBag right.mufc1959 wrote:Looks as if things might have escalated for poor old GOOFY murph75.
http://getoutofdebtfree.org/forum/viewt ... 49#p376558
If people from Poland are called Poles Why are aren't people from Holland called Holes?
-
- Admiral of the Quatloosian Seas
- Posts: 2186
- Joined: Sat Oct 25, 2014 9:58 pm
Re: UK DD clawbacks and Simon Goldberg
Or to paraphrase :- Huh? You're not supposed to notice that I'm defrauding you! I demand that you look the other way and let me unlawfully enrich myself by false representation!mufc1959 wrote:Looks as if things might have escalated for poor old GOOFY murph75.
http://getoutofdebtfree.org/forum/viewt ... 49#p376558Thieving Murphy wrote:I am also shocked to read the content of your letter dated 8th April 2015 which states you are investigating claims of direct debit indemnity fraud. You categorically told me on the phone that you wasn't accusing me of fraud, yet
"don't be hubris ever..." Steve Mccrae, noted legal ExpertInFuckAll.
-
- Admiral of the Quatloosian Seas
- Posts: 660
- Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2014 1:33 pm
Re: UK DD clawbacks and Simon Goldberg
That link is LOADS of fun. Caveat: I have a guilty, uncivilized pleasure of watching people harm themselves.mufc1959 wrote:Looks as if things might have escalated for poor old GOOFY murph75.
http://getoutofdebtfree.org/forum/viewt ... 49#p376558
First good laugh: other posters (with the apparent exception of aarons1950) are encouraging him to continue on course - while he is full well knowing he's being investigated for Fraud - something that usually can be expected to bring criminal charges and jail time.
Next good laugh:
Well... the obvious suggestion is that he follow up with appropriate Legal representation, fully disclose what he did and why, and find out if he really did commit fraud. If so, the stress is all his own creation.I have banked with the nationwide building society for over 37 years and to be dealing with the fraud investigation department is causing me severe alarm and distress.
Third chuckle: apparently he believes the investigation into the direct debit reversal request would require the Bank to follow up with a third party (assuming it was a third-party that did the direct debit) and legally verify any contractual obligations he may have with third-party. Bzzzzz - no such luck. Without any kind of Court Order, I doubt the third party is required to disclose anything with the bank. The claim of Fraud likely came from said third party after the funds had been reversed.
Next good laugh: he's provided the previous conversation for review - not in the post, just his correspondence with the bank, and assuming the conversation actually occurred and the notes can be trusted to reflect the reality of the time and have not been modified. That's the prime problem with OPCA types, they establish a pretty large lack of credibility very early on. Perhaps he should re-review his own notes to see if he was totally honest with the situation or even if he's being totally honest with himself.
From what I can see with regards Northern Rock - mentioned in the correspondence and assuming I have the correct entity identified - it looks like a building society that turned bank which was then acquired by Virgin Money. So perhaps he clawed back mortgage funds - that could be a pretty significant ouch he can look forward to.
-
- Admiral of the Quatloosian Seas
- Posts: 2249
- Joined: Wed Dec 01, 2010 8:00 pm
- Location: Soho London
Re: UK DD clawbacks and Simon Goldberg
The idiot has clawed back £26000 which was mortgage payments.
http://getoutofdebtfree.org/forum/viewt ... 23#p326023
This should be a barrel of laughs.
http://getoutofdebtfree.org/forum/viewt ... 23#p326023
This should be a barrel of laughs.
BHF wrote:
It shows your mentality to think someone would make the effort to post something on the internet that was untrue.
It shows your mentality to think someone would make the effort to post something on the internet that was untrue.
-
- Stern Faced Schoolmaster of Serious Discussion
- Posts: 1363
- Joined: Wed Oct 29, 2014 7:12 am
- Location: England, UK
Re: UK DD clawbacks and Simon Goldberg
Yes, it was a mortgage:
murphy wrote:3 Weeks to finally get my clawback from Nationwide BS, it was for my mortgage payments from Northern rock from 2007 - 2009
Just git £26,000 credited to my account
-
- Admiral of the Quatloosian Seas
- Posts: 1186
- Joined: Sun Feb 08, 2015 2:47 pm
- Location: Manchester by day, Slaithwaite by night
Re: UK DD clawbacks and Simon Goldberg
I bet his next step will be a complaint to the ombudsman. They'll have a lot of sympathy for his unfortunate predicament.
http://www.ombudsman-decisions.org.uk/v ... leID=57469
http://www.ombudsman-decisions.org.uk/v ... leID=69601
The second decision is quite amusing where the ombudsman has to explain to Ms G that a writ of habeus corpus has got nothing to do with a mortgage.
http://www.ombudsman-decisions.org.uk/v ... leID=57469
http://www.ombudsman-decisions.org.uk/v ... leID=69601
The second decision is quite amusing where the ombudsman has to explain to Ms G that a writ of habeus corpus has got nothing to do with a mortgage.
-
- Admiral of the Quatloosian Seas
- Posts: 2186
- Joined: Sat Oct 25, 2014 9:58 pm
Re: UK DD clawbacks and Simon Goldberg
And now you've just git £26,000 added to your mortgage debt, with the result that you are now in massive arrears. If you double your monthly payments then you might be able to clear it before you reach retirement age. Otherwise the bank will take your home and sell it to recover what you owe them. And all the time, you'll be paying interest on it.littleFred wrote:Yes, it was a mortgage:Thieving Murphy wrote:Just git £26,000 credited to my account etc...
Well done, Murphy - you've taught those Zionist Nazi bankers a lesson....
"don't be hubris ever..." Steve Mccrae, noted legal ExpertInFuckAll.
-
- Admiral of the Quatloosian Seas
- Posts: 1186
- Joined: Sun Feb 08, 2015 2:47 pm
- Location: Manchester by day, Slaithwaite by night
Re: UK DD clawbacks and Simon Goldberg
If it was 2007-2009, he might not have that mortgage any more. In which case Northern Rock might be thinking about reporting it to the police.
-
- Slavering Minister of Auto-erotic Insinuation
- Posts: 3759
- Joined: Thu Sep 30, 2010 9:35 am
- Location: Quatloos Immigration Control
Re: UK DD clawbacks and Simon Goldberg
I'm wondering if his action coincided with one of the periods of financial turmoil at various banks and building societies at the time, and his "refund" slipped through the net.mufc1959 wrote:If it was 2007-2009, he might not have that mortgage any more. In which case Northern Rock might be thinking about reporting it to the police.
I also await (as I think I mentioned here previously), the lender to reset the loan back to the start date minus the refund. One of these sovcit types will hold the British record for mortgage arrears at like 96 months missed payments. Bear in mind, here it used to be the case that 6 months arrears was really bad, hardly anyone would lend you money, and then it would be at 40% apr and have to be secured. Beyond 9 months arrears you were pretty well untouchable as a borrower. These jokers are 4-10 times beyond that.
"There is something about true madness that goes beyond mere eccentricity." Will Self
-
- Admiral of the Quatloosian Seas
- Posts: 1581
- Joined: Thu Jun 19, 2014 7:11 pm
- Location: In a gallery, with Peanuts.
Re: UK DD clawbacks and Simon Goldberg
Apparently the clawback was in October 2014. I'd think it's likely that a mistake was made somewhere along the lines, in terms of allowing the clawback, and now the bank are dealing with a rather unhappy Northern Rock Asset Management department asking where their money is.
If the mortgage has been discharged, then this may prove to be an interesting legal conundrum, however if not then the matter would be simpler to deal with. Based on the limited information we have in which Murphy has not indicated that they have had any contact from Northern Rock, I would think that the mortgage had been discharged when Murphy made the clawback.
In this case NRAM may need to get a court order to reinstate the mortgage and then apply the arrears. In the meantime both banks will likely be treating this as fraud. Which is what it seems to be.
I'd also just highlight this excerpt from a passage of Murphy's own letter to Nationwide.
If the mortgage has been discharged, then this may prove to be an interesting legal conundrum, however if not then the matter would be simpler to deal with. Based on the limited information we have in which Murphy has not indicated that they have had any contact from Northern Rock, I would think that the mortgage had been discharged when Murphy made the clawback.
In this case NRAM may need to get a court order to reinstate the mortgage and then apply the arrears. In the meantime both banks will likely be treating this as fraud. Which is what it seems to be.
I'd also just highlight this excerpt from a passage of Murphy's own letter to Nationwide.
Murphy75 wrote:You categorically told me on the phone that you wasn't accusing me of fraud, yet
* Emphasis mine
Warning may contain traces of nut
-
- A Balthazar of Quatloosian Truth
- Posts: 13806
- Joined: Mon Jul 04, 2005 7:17 pm
Re: UK DD clawbacks and Simon Goldberg
What amazes me is that this financial genius doesn't seem to get the yet part. If this really was over a mortgage, the bank/lender as was pointed out can go back to court and have the cancellation voided for fraud, seize the property for non-payment, and then just for good measure file wire fraud charges against the doofus. I have a hard time imagining why and how he got away with it, but I still don't see why he thinks he should get away with it. The level of I'm not sure just what boggles the mind.
The fact that you sincerely and wholeheartedly believe that the “Law of Gravity” is unconstitutional and a violation of your sovereign rights, does not absolve you of adherence to it.
-
- Stern Faced Schoolmaster of Serious Discussion
- Posts: 1363
- Joined: Wed Oct 29, 2014 7:12 am
- Location: England, UK
Re: UK DD clawbacks and Simon Goldberg
I don't think he has got away with it. On the contrary, I expect civil and criminal proceedings will follow.notorial dissent wrote:I have a hard time imagining why and how he got away with it ...
Crimes are always possible. Theft, murder, whatever. GOOFers don't seem that realise that merely because something is possible, this doesn't give them a right to do it.
-
- Admiral of the Quatloosian Seas
- Posts: 1186
- Joined: Sun Feb 08, 2015 2:47 pm
- Location: Manchester by day, Slaithwaite by night
Re: UK DD clawbacks and Simon Goldberg
The one silver lining for murphy75 is that, once he's blacklisted by every bank because of the CIFAS (fraud) markers against his name, there's one bank which will be happy to welcome him as a new customer and will deposit £150K into his account as a welcome handshake ...
-
- Admiral of the Quatloosian Seas
- Posts: 1874
- Joined: Sun Apr 19, 2015 11:12 am
- Location: Laughing at Tuco
Re: UK DD clawbacks and Simon Goldberg
The Direct Debit Indemnity is heavily weighted in favour of the customer and there isn't really anything to stop someone claiming back any payment made by DD.PeanutGallery wrote:Apparently the clawback was in October 2014. I'd think it's likely that a mistake was made somewhere along the lines, in terms of allowing the clawback, and now the bank are dealing with a rather unhappy Northern Rock Asset Management department asking where their money is.
However, obviously to make a dd claim, you usually give a reason and it will be the reason given that will be fraudulent - i.e didn't owe the money, payment were taken in error etc.
Even Rabbit man isn't this stupid, to reclaim mortgage payments, he pays in good old cold hard cash over the counter.
-
- Admiral of the Quatloosian Seas
- Posts: 1581
- Joined: Thu Jun 19, 2014 7:11 pm
- Location: In a gallery, with Peanuts.
Re: UK DD clawbacks and Simon Goldberg
Having recently discovered GooF jimmyw's youtube channel I thought I would give it a look to see if it contained any of the regular sovrun gems. While browsing I noticed this video, in which jimmy gloats about having defrauded Moorcroft and another company of around £5,000.00.
This obviously could have ramifications for Jimmy. Especially if on one of his video's he gave his name as Jim Wild and in a posting on another video claims to live in Huddersfield.
This obviously could have ramifications for Jimmy. Especially if on one of his video's he gave his name as Jim Wild and in a posting on another video claims to live in Huddersfield.
Warning may contain traces of nut