That sort of thing happens all the time, without so many appeals and cases. But crummy car dealers commit fraud and if Lawyers get involved before repossession then sometimes the bank will let the person hang on to the car until resolution.davidthompson wrote:Ok, had to join after i saw this wacky stuff pop up on suijuris.com and another site and have been checking this out on pacer. So the deal seems to be as follows:
you buy a car, an expensive one, then decide not to pay for it, then two years later, several county court rulings, 6 middle court filings (between the vehicle and a credit card) 4 appeals, a few suggestions of middle court judge treason and subsequent suggestions of execution, 30 or so maritime liens on various bank directors and board members and YOU STILL HAVEN'T HAD TO RETURN THE CAR...nice gig if you can get it....
This opinion is a hoot
Re: This opinion is a hoot
Re: This opinion is a hoot
Good point, except this car dealer appears to have posted a 100K bond (usually twice the amount of the vehicle held until case can be heard) for a writ of replevin almost two years ago and still waiting for resolution.
Re: This opinion is a hoot
That one is different.davidthompson wrote:Good point, except this car dealer appears to have posted a 100K bond (usually twice the amount of the vehicle held until case can be heard) for a writ of replevin almost two years ago and still waiting for resolution.
Just a guess, but I would guess that if the Car Dealer is still in on it that they could not sell the paper. Again that's kind of different because two to three years ago car dealers were still making up incomes and addresses, so either we have here an honest car dealer who did a little research after the papers were signed but before they were sold to a bank or servicer, or a dealer who couldn't sell them for whatever reason.
Either way I have to wonder why not charge the guy for hiding collateral and be done with it.
Re: This opinion is a hoot
When I started reading the opinion, I noticed the state, but not the name.
Until I checked the name, I thought it was our old buddy Heidi, who had major issues with paying her debts.
Until I checked the name, I thought it was our old buddy Heidi, who had major issues with paying her debts.
Re: This opinion is a hoot
No idea, this civil suit was orignally filed by the car dealer AND the finance company. According to the stuff on Pacer, she changed her mind about making any payments as soon as she drove off the lot and started with her sovereign citizen/strawman arguments when her first payment was due. Hmmm wonder why more people don't try this, always nice to have a new ride for a few years if the only penalty is a couple of court appearances ....I have been researching this movement for a few months now for a paper and i never fail to be amazed by the stuff they get away with.bmielke wrote:That one is different.davidthompson wrote:Good point, except this car dealer appears to have posted a 100K bond (usually twice the amount of the vehicle held until case can be heard) for a writ of replevin almost two years ago and still waiting for resolution.
Just a guess, but I would guess that if the Car Dealer is still in on it that they could not sell the paper. Again that's kind of different because two to three years ago car dealers were still making up incomes and addresses, so either we have here an honest car dealer who did a little research after the papers were signed but before they were sold to a bank or servicer, or a dealer who couldn't sell them for whatever reason.
Either way I have to wonder why not charge the guy for hiding collateral and be done with it.
Re: This opinion is a hoot
Ah, I though your were talking about another case os Sooey (for some reason, reading is fundamental and sometimes I don't do it right) I'll have to look this one up, I assumed when I saw bank, crazy women, and Florida that this was a Foreclosure turned real ugly but a car thing is right up my alley.davidthompson wrote:No idea, this civil suit was orignally filed by the car dealer AND the finance company. According to the stuff on Pacer, she changed her mind about making any payments as soon as she drove off the lot and started with her sovereign citizen/strawman arguments when her first payment was due. Hmmm wonder why more people don't try this, always nice to have a new ride for a few years if the only penalty is a couple of court appearances ....I have been researching this movement for a few months now for a paper and i never fail to be amazed by the stuff they get away with.bmielke wrote:That one is different.davidthompson wrote:Good point, except this car dealer appears to have posted a 100K bond (usually twice the amount of the vehicle held until case can be heard) for a writ of replevin almost two years ago and still waiting for resolution.
Just a guess, but I would guess that if the Car Dealer is still in on it that they could not sell the paper. Again that's kind of different because two to three years ago car dealers were still making up incomes and addresses, so either we have here an honest car dealer who did a little research after the papers were signed but before they were sold to a bank or servicer, or a dealer who couldn't sell them for whatever reason.
Either way I have to wonder why not charge the guy for hiding collateral and be done with it.
-
- Conde de Quatloo
- Posts: 5631
- Joined: Fri May 21, 2004 5:08 am
- Location: Der Dachshundbünker
Re: This opinion is a hoot
If the car is leased, why doesn't the finance company refuse to get tags for the car....hell, if the lease is in default and they have an order of some kind granting them possession, why not report it as stolen?
Supreme Commander of The Imperial Illuminati Air Force
Your concern is duly noted, filed, folded, stamped, sealed with wax and affixed with a thumbprint in red ink, forgotten, recalled, considered, reconsidered, appealed, denied and quietly ignored.
Your concern is duly noted, filed, folded, stamped, sealed with wax and affixed with a thumbprint in red ink, forgotten, recalled, considered, reconsidered, appealed, denied and quietly ignored.
Re: This opinion is a hoot
I agree, and if she's hiding it, then why haven't charges been filed, at least in Tennessee it is a Felony to hide collateral.Gregg wrote:If the car is leased, why doesn't the finance company refuse to get tags for the car....hell, if the lease is in default and they have an order of some kind granting them possession, why not report it as stolen?
Re: This opinion is a hoot
we should probably post this here:
http://forums.randi.org/showthread.php?t=176930
they would love it
http://forums.randi.org/showthread.php?t=176930
they would love it
Re: This opinion is a hoot
LPC wrote:Best description ever of the tax denier mindset.In common with other so-called sovereign citizens, she appears to believe that ours is a legal system, not of statutes and precedent, but of sorcery, with parties prevailing as a result of their incantation of out-of-context passages from Black’s Legal Dictionary.
I agree... An excellent example of Irish diplomacy.
I like the Judge's mindset but wouldn't it have been easier if he'd just said "Dismissed because the plaintiff is a dumb-a$$"
-
- Cannoneer
- Posts: 94
- Joined: Fri Feb 25, 2005 9:25 pm
Re: This opinion is a hoot
Much as we laugh at sovereign idiocies, the perpetrators of this gibberish are able to take advantage of State court systems which bend over backwards to provide "due process" and "fair play" with resulting injustice to honest folks who play by the rules and are simply trying to collect just debts that are due.
Here is a case study in collecting a small claim in Maine against a Sovereign who wants to play the deadbeat game. Let's say Sovereign owes you $10,000 on a signed Promissory Note. File Complaint. Pay Filing Fee. Send Summons and Complaint by Certified Mail. Pay postage. Certified mail refused. Have Summons and Complaint served by Deputy Sheriff. Pay for service of process. (Deputy may have to make several efforts to serve deadbeat Sovereign and you will pay for each attempt). Proof of Service filed in Court. File Motion for Prejudgment Attachment. and Attachement on Trustee Process With luck, Court will grant Attachment. If so, file Attachment in Registry of Deeds and pay filing fee. Chances are that Sovereign owns no real property or is hiding it in the name of his "Pure Trust" so Attachment will not be effective. Serve Trustee Process on banks and others holding property of Sovereign to "freeze" the asset for future satisfaction of judgment. (Chances are that your Trustee process comes up empty). Sovereign has 20 days to answer. Sovereign defaults and fails to answer within the allowed time. File Notice of Default. After 30 days file Motion for Entry of Default Judgment. Serve motion on Sovereign. Sovereign has 3 weeks to respond and files Motion to Set Aside Notice of Default. Motion set for hearing (with luck within 30 days). Court finds that justice requires that Sovereign have a chance to be heard and grants another 30 days to file Answer. Let's assume Sovereign files an Answer denying that he owes you the money and demanding to be "shown the Note." Court schedules PreTrial Conference (hopefully within 30 days). At PreTrial Conference Court sets schedule for discovery and motions (possibly 90 days, 120 days, or 180 days). Discovery ensues (Requests for Production of Documents and records, Written Interrogatories, Requests for Admissions, Deposition Notices). Sovereign fails to comply. File Motion to compel production of discovery. Wait 30-60 days for hearing. Judge (probably) allows Sovereign another 30 days to comply. Most likely Sovereign fails to comply. Motion for Contempt and Sanctions. Judge (probably) allows Sovereign additional time to comply. After all, its only fair to give him some time. Let's assume that Sovereign complies. Possible Motion for Summary Judgment (although Court unlikely to grant if there is even the slightest factual dispute over the amount due or an assertion by Sovereign that he was orally granted an extension of time to pay or asserts some sort of defense or counterclaim). Motion denied. On trial list waiting for court date (3 to 6 months). Trial. Court does not accept Sovereign's lying testimony that there was an oral agreement that he didn't have to pay. Judgment for Plaintiff (with costs plus statutory interest and attorneys fees if the Note so provides). Wait for 30 day appeal period to run. (Let's not bother with the delays and expenses of processing an appeal and pretend that no appeal is filed.) Request Writ of Execution. Serve Writ of Execution (Pay Deputy Sheriff). Deputy returns writ unsatisfied. Record Writ of Execution in Registry of Deeds and file with Secretary of State (Pay Filing Fees). File Motion for Collection Disclosure Hearing. Deputy Sheriff serves Motion on Sovereign to appear and examined (Pay Deputy). Schedule hearing (1-3 months). Disclosure hearing before Judge. Hopefully Judge will order asset turn over or installment payments or some other form of collection. Maybe you can even get an order of trustee process on Sovereign's employer (our equivalent to garnishment). But since Sovereign is probably cleaning pools for cash under the table your trustee process will come up empty. Sovereign defaults and fails to pay. Motion for Contempt. Schedule new Disclosure Hearing Rinse, recycle, and repeat.
If you're keeping score at home, you've been kept waiting for a couple of years and have had to pay a lot of filing fees and court costs and put up with tons of aggravation and you still haven't collected a nickel. We've provided Sovereign with lots of due process, fair play and opportunity to be heard. Not so much to you.
Of course, I can flip the story and rattle on about comparable abuses by the creditors' side. We can talk about "sewer service" and false affidavits and inadequate record keeping and outright deceit by creditors and their counsel some other time.
We need less process and more justice.
Here is a case study in collecting a small claim in Maine against a Sovereign who wants to play the deadbeat game. Let's say Sovereign owes you $10,000 on a signed Promissory Note. File Complaint. Pay Filing Fee. Send Summons and Complaint by Certified Mail. Pay postage. Certified mail refused. Have Summons and Complaint served by Deputy Sheriff. Pay for service of process. (Deputy may have to make several efforts to serve deadbeat Sovereign and you will pay for each attempt). Proof of Service filed in Court. File Motion for Prejudgment Attachment. and Attachement on Trustee Process With luck, Court will grant Attachment. If so, file Attachment in Registry of Deeds and pay filing fee. Chances are that Sovereign owns no real property or is hiding it in the name of his "Pure Trust" so Attachment will not be effective. Serve Trustee Process on banks and others holding property of Sovereign to "freeze" the asset for future satisfaction of judgment. (Chances are that your Trustee process comes up empty). Sovereign has 20 days to answer. Sovereign defaults and fails to answer within the allowed time. File Notice of Default. After 30 days file Motion for Entry of Default Judgment. Serve motion on Sovereign. Sovereign has 3 weeks to respond and files Motion to Set Aside Notice of Default. Motion set for hearing (with luck within 30 days). Court finds that justice requires that Sovereign have a chance to be heard and grants another 30 days to file Answer. Let's assume Sovereign files an Answer denying that he owes you the money and demanding to be "shown the Note." Court schedules PreTrial Conference (hopefully within 30 days). At PreTrial Conference Court sets schedule for discovery and motions (possibly 90 days, 120 days, or 180 days). Discovery ensues (Requests for Production of Documents and records, Written Interrogatories, Requests for Admissions, Deposition Notices). Sovereign fails to comply. File Motion to compel production of discovery. Wait 30-60 days for hearing. Judge (probably) allows Sovereign another 30 days to comply. Most likely Sovereign fails to comply. Motion for Contempt and Sanctions. Judge (probably) allows Sovereign additional time to comply. After all, its only fair to give him some time. Let's assume that Sovereign complies. Possible Motion for Summary Judgment (although Court unlikely to grant if there is even the slightest factual dispute over the amount due or an assertion by Sovereign that he was orally granted an extension of time to pay or asserts some sort of defense or counterclaim). Motion denied. On trial list waiting for court date (3 to 6 months). Trial. Court does not accept Sovereign's lying testimony that there was an oral agreement that he didn't have to pay. Judgment for Plaintiff (with costs plus statutory interest and attorneys fees if the Note so provides). Wait for 30 day appeal period to run. (Let's not bother with the delays and expenses of processing an appeal and pretend that no appeal is filed.) Request Writ of Execution. Serve Writ of Execution (Pay Deputy Sheriff). Deputy returns writ unsatisfied. Record Writ of Execution in Registry of Deeds and file with Secretary of State (Pay Filing Fees). File Motion for Collection Disclosure Hearing. Deputy Sheriff serves Motion on Sovereign to appear and examined (Pay Deputy). Schedule hearing (1-3 months). Disclosure hearing before Judge. Hopefully Judge will order asset turn over or installment payments or some other form of collection. Maybe you can even get an order of trustee process on Sovereign's employer (our equivalent to garnishment). But since Sovereign is probably cleaning pools for cash under the table your trustee process will come up empty. Sovereign defaults and fails to pay. Motion for Contempt. Schedule new Disclosure Hearing Rinse, recycle, and repeat.
If you're keeping score at home, you've been kept waiting for a couple of years and have had to pay a lot of filing fees and court costs and put up with tons of aggravation and you still haven't collected a nickel. We've provided Sovereign with lots of due process, fair play and opportunity to be heard. Not so much to you.
Of course, I can flip the story and rattle on about comparable abuses by the creditors' side. We can talk about "sewer service" and false affidavits and inadequate record keeping and outright deceit by creditors and their counsel some other time.
We need less process and more justice.
-
- Infidel Enslaver
- Posts: 895
- Joined: Sat Mar 03, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: This opinion is a hoot
Out-of-the-box debtors require out-of-the-box creditors.
Form a shell company in Medellin, Columbia, and assign the debt to that company. Let it slip to debtor in some filing that the creditor is a company in Medellin. Offer to Sovereign that debt will be settled with debtor paying no actual money, but Medellin company wants to take a large life insurance policy on debtor's life. Express that owners of Medellin company are "very unhappy" that Sovereign is making no effort to pay.
These days, a company formed in Juarez, Mexico, will work just as well for this purpose.
Form a shell company in Medellin, Columbia, and assign the debt to that company. Let it slip to debtor in some filing that the creditor is a company in Medellin. Offer to Sovereign that debt will be settled with debtor paying no actual money, but Medellin company wants to take a large life insurance policy on debtor's life. Express that owners of Medellin company are "very unhappy" that Sovereign is making no effort to pay.
These days, a company formed in Juarez, Mexico, will work just as well for this purpose.
- - - - - - - - - - -
"The real George Washington was shot dead fairly early in the Revolution." ~ David Merrill, 9-17-2004 --- "This is where I belong" ~ Heidi Guedel, 7-1-2006 (referring to suijuris.net)
- - - - - - - - - - -
"The real George Washington was shot dead fairly early in the Revolution." ~ David Merrill, 9-17-2004 --- "This is where I belong" ~ Heidi Guedel, 7-1-2006 (referring to suijuris.net)
- - - - - - - - - - -
-
- Conde de Quatloo
- Posts: 5631
- Joined: Fri May 21, 2004 5:08 am
- Location: Der Dachshundbünker
Re: This opinion is a hoot
Pay $500 to biker gang/collection specialists, get paid in a week.Joey Smith wrote:Out-of-the-box debtors require out-of-the-box creditors.
Form a shell company in Medellin, Columbia, and assign the debt to that company. Let it slip to debtor in some filing that the creditor is a company in Medellin. Offer to Sovereign that debt will be settled with debtor paying no actual money, but Medellin company wants to take a large life insurance policy on debtor's life. Express that owners of Medellin company are "very unhappy" that Sovereign is making no effort to pay.
These days, a company formed in Juarez, Mexico, will work just as well for this purpose.
Supreme Commander of The Imperial Illuminati Air Force
Your concern is duly noted, filed, folded, stamped, sealed with wax and affixed with a thumbprint in red ink, forgotten, recalled, considered, reconsidered, appealed, denied and quietly ignored.
Your concern is duly noted, filed, folded, stamped, sealed with wax and affixed with a thumbprint in red ink, forgotten, recalled, considered, reconsidered, appealed, denied and quietly ignored.
-
- Emperor of rodents, foreign and domestic
- Posts: 378
- Joined: Thu Jun 21, 2007 4:24 pm
- Location: All holed up in Minnesota with a bunch of nuts
Re: This opinion is a hoot
Would have been what I would have thought. Grand theft auto of theft by swindle, as it is obvious she never intended to pay.Gregg wrote:If the car is leased, why doesn't the finance company refuse to get tags for the car....hell, if the lease is in default and they have an order of some kind granting them possession, why not report it as stolen?
Are you saying that Ron Paul serves as a convenient chew toy to keep stupid puppies occupied so they don't roll in the garbage? -grixit
-
- Judge for the District of Quatloosia
- Posts: 3704
- Joined: Tue May 17, 2005 6:04 pm
- Location: West of the Pecos
Re: This opinion is a hoot
It sounds easier than it really is. I know someone who did it for a living for a long, long time. The hardest ones are those people who aren't employed and have friends who help them hide. And there are places even a repo man won't go without a law enforcement escort.CaptainKickback wrote:...
Wouldn't it be simpler (and cheaper) to just send out the repo man to get the car back?
The Honorable Judge Roy Bean
The world is a car and you're a crash-test dummy.
The Devil Makes Three
The world is a car and you're a crash-test dummy.
The Devil Makes Three
-
- Warder of the Quatloosian Gibbet
- Posts: 1206
- Joined: Mon Oct 25, 2004 8:43 pm
Re: This opinion is a hoot
Good Lord what a sad, damaged creature. She will probably end up homeless or institutionalized in short order.
-
- Conde de Quatloo
- Posts: 5631
- Joined: Fri May 21, 2004 5:08 am
- Location: Der Dachshundbünker
Re: This opinion is a hoot
Normally, but in Florida she'll end up on the Board of Elections
Supreme Commander of The Imperial Illuminati Air Force
Your concern is duly noted, filed, folded, stamped, sealed with wax and affixed with a thumbprint in red ink, forgotten, recalled, considered, reconsidered, appealed, denied and quietly ignored.
Your concern is duly noted, filed, folded, stamped, sealed with wax and affixed with a thumbprint in red ink, forgotten, recalled, considered, reconsidered, appealed, denied and quietly ignored.
-
- Fourth Shogun of Quatloosia
- Posts: 885
- Joined: Sat Jul 21, 2007 3:04 pm
- Location: Here, I used to be there, but I moved.
Re: This opinion is a hoot
Automatically invalidated since the second witness didn't sign with the full colonic version of his name. I am sure there are plenty of other magical woo-woo errors that the brainiacs at Sui will say is the reason why her UCC filing didn't save any of her assets.
Light travels faster than sound, which is why some people appear bright, until you hear them speak.